"There were two things that especially attracted me to the ideas of renormalization and quantum field theory. One of them was that the requirement that a physical theory be renormalizable is a precise and rational criterion of simplicity. In a sense, this requirement had been used long before the advent of renormalization theory. When Dirac wrote down the Dirac equation in 1928 he could have added an extra ‘Pauli’ term ... which would have given the electron an arbitrary anomalous magnetic moment. Dirac could (and perhaps did) say ‘I won’t add this term because it’s ugly and complicated and there’s no need for it.’ I think that in physics this approach generally makes good strategies but bad rationales. It’s often a good strategy to study simple theories before you study complicated theories because it’s easier to see how they work, but the purpose of physics is to find out why nature is the way it is, and simplicity by itself is I think never the answer. But renormalizability was a condition of simplicity which was being imposed for what seemed after Dyson’s 1949 papers ... like a rational reason, and it explained not only why the electron has the magnetic moment it has, but also (together with gauge symmetries) all the detailed features of the standard model of weak, electromagnetic, and strong, interactions, aside from some numerical parameters. The other thing I liked about quantum field theory during this period of tremendous optimism was that it offered a clear answer to the ancient question of what we mean by an elementary particle: it is simply a particle whose field appears in the Lagrangian. It doesn’t matter if it’s stable, unstable, heavy, light — if its field appears in the Lagrangian then it’s elementary, otherwise it’s composite."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Steven Weinberg, (quote from pp. 3–4)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Particle
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Particle
4 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Particle →
Related Quotes
"David J. Griffiths, Introduction to Quantum Mechanics (2nd ed., 2016), pp. 3–4"
"... Where was the particle just before I made the measurement? There are three plausible answers to this question, an…"
"One of the fundamental concepts of mechanics is that of a particle. By this we mean a body whose dimensions may be ne…"
"There has always been a good deal of mystery surrounding the pinch harmonic, or, as hip players like to call it, “pic…"
"In short, pick squealing, or pinch harmonics is part of the reason why a lot of people started using copious amounts …"
"The way I and most guitarists produce a pinch harmonic is to grasp the pick close to its pointed tip with your thumb …"
"When you pick the string just right, a higher pitch other than the fretted note is sounded. This higher pitch is an o…"
"2. Are there any new elementary scalars not yet discovered with masses below the mass of the -like Higgs boson? For e…"
"The last few decades have provided abundant evidence for physics beyond the two standard models of particle physics a…"
"With the discovery of the Higgs boson, the next burning question at the LHC is why its mass is so low. Nobody knows t…"