"The determination of the Indo-European civilization is precisely the point which affords least hope of any satisfactory result. It rests on linguistic evidence pure and simple, and it is open to the gravest doubt whether such evidence is capable of giving the results which are claimed for it by those who seek to determine the Indo-European home. . . . It should suffice to remember that on the basis usually adopted we would have to conclude that the Indo-Europeans knew snow and feet, but were ignorant of rain and hands. The difficulty, of course, is in theory recognized by all who deal with the issue; the trouble is that in practice they tend more or less completely to ignore it, and to create for us a picture of the Indo-Europeans which is probably a mere delusive shadow of the actual civilization of the people. Yet it should be a warning when we find that linguistically we may assert that the Indo-Europeans knew butter but were unacquainted with milk. (189-190)"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Keith, A. B. 1933. "The Home of the Indo-Europeans." In Oriental Studies in Honour of Cursetji Eracliji Pavry (188-199). Ed. J. D. Pavry. London: Oxford University Press. (189-190) quoted in Bryant, E. F. (2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture : the Indo-Aryan migration debate. Oxford University Press.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Paleolinguistics
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Paleolinguistics
13 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Paleolinguistics →
Related Quotes
"The extent to which one can accept or deny the premises of ‘archaeo-linguistics’ depends on the extent of one’s faith…"
"All prehistoric reconstruction is of course purely hypothetical, that is, based on conjectural assumptions. Strictly …"
"The apparent existence of a common term in the language, which is attained through reconstruction on the basis of the…"
"The linguist J. Fraser (1926),for example, presented a well-known (but faulty) caricature of the whole enterprise by …"
"Now the more sophisticated among us could easily object here that it would take a great deal of naivete on the part o…"
"The English language has laid under contribution almost every language on the face of the earth. We speak freely of t…"
"It is an elementary mistake to equate common Indo-European words with Proto-Indo-European words and to base thereon c…"
"The arbitrary and unrigorous methods that have characterized much of this linguistic paleontology certainly deserve R…"
"The clues afforded by linguistic paleontology were either so general that they accommodated both centres without much…"
"Most recently, Krell (1998) argued that "the old, pliable crutch of linguistic paleontology should certainly be aband…"