"Americans divide Indians into two categories: the noble savage and the howling savage. The noble savage is seen as the appealing but doomed victim of the inevitable evolution of humanity from primitive to postindustrial social orders. The American belief in progress and evolution makes this a particularly difficult idea to dislodge, even though it is a root cause of the genocide practiced against American Indians since the colonial period. This attitude, which I characterize as the Progressive Fallacy, allows American Indians victim status only. And while its adherents suffer some anguish when encountering the brutal facts of exterminationist policies, they inevitably shrug resignedly and say—quite directly—that Indians have to assimilate or perish. So while the Progressives allow the noble savage to be the guardian of the wilds and on occasion the conscience of ecological responsibility, the end result of their view for Indians is the same as its counterpart view of American Indians as howling denizens of a terrifying wilderness."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Paula Gunn Allen, Introduction
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Noble_savage
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Noble savage
2 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Noble savage →
Related Quotes
"Historically the focus on resistance had powerful political uses in emancipating individuals from feudal authority. T…"
"There are many dark chapters in mankind's history ranging from transatlantic slave trade to holocaust to dropping of …"
"Intensive studies of individual tribes are very important and I think ASI (ie. the Anthropological Survey of India) w…"
"What is now required is a carefully and scientifically edited Dictionary or Gazetteer of the Castes, and Tribes, and …"
"I am not free as long as one person of Color remains chained. Nor is any one of you."
"The Laiharaoba is the bedrock on which the entire Meitei civilization rests."
"Credit should be given to the ancient Meitei civilization of Manipur to identify the Southern Zeliangrong area by the…"
"Hakchang saba describes the birth and growth of the child and the subsequent processes of agriculture and house const…"
"Moirang had a peculiar relationship with the Meiteis, who needed to appease and appropriate its pride, independence, …"
"Lai Haraoba stands supreme, have successfully preserved the essence of the Meitei civilization and world-view."