"Now in Avestan ‘lake/pool’ is vairi-. In fact Avestan has no verb or nouns cognate to the Sanskrit ones √sṛ >sar-. The only cognation is harah- in the name of the river harahvaiti – nothing else. But S √sṛ >sar- is a perfectly PIE morpheme appearing in Tocharian B sal-ate, Gk hiallō/hallomai and Latin salire all implying ‘moving, jumping’. Avestan somehow lost this root and its derivatives. So, how did the Iranians manage to concoct this name Harahvaiti, that sounds so exactly like a transliteration of the Vedic Sarasvatī , when they had no words from √sṛ > sar-? Adherents of the AIT offer no rational answers. (For full discussion see Kazanas 2004b, Prabhakar 1994/1995.) There is only one possible explanation. The Iranians, having lived in Saptasindhu moved to Iran (retaining the memory of the place as Haptahәndu); on meeting an amenable river there they gave it the name of the river they had formerly known – Sarasvati > Harahvaiti. The AIT can in no way, except by violating rationality, explain the two Avestan names Haptahәndu and Harahvaiti. This, if nothing else, should have alerted the AIT adherents to the possibility that there is something very seriously wrong in their migrationist scenario. Moreover, it is part of the general linguistic theory that the Avestan h derives from PIE s: so, it is again extremely difficult to see how the IAs who moved further southeast, retained the original s (in saras and saptasindhu) while the Iranians changed it to h."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Indo-Aryan indigenism and the Aryan Invasion Theory arguments (refuted). N Kazanas, Omilos Meleton, Athens, January 2006.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Nicholas_Kazanas
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Nicholas Kazanas
35 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Nicholas Kazanas →
Related Quotes
"I have seriously changed my mind on this subject; I have no axe to grind, as it were, no position or reputation to ma…"
"The Aryans, even according to the AIT, moved not into a vacuum but a region thickly populated by a people who may hav…"
"Neither the AIT, nor the invasionists’ or non-invasionists’ views, nor IE reconstructions, nor philological, archeolo…"
"So sarcasm should be aimed at in that direction also - unless W practises discriminatory self-restraint... the isoglo…"
"Such were the motives of the mainstream pundits who were also pillars of the Church: to preserve their own power. Why…"
"And in case these academics wonder, yes, I would allow a dissenting view if I edited a Journal: I am not afraid of tr…"
"Why does he attack this group of Indians and allies himself to a group of marxists, like the editors of Frontline? A …"
"The odd thing about this story is that the heliocentric view was known in Europe long before Copernicus but, for vari…"
"The situation whereby the Aryans are indigenous and compose the bulk of the [Rg Veda] in the 4th millennium in Saptas…"
"I start with some literary evidence. RV 4.1.13 & 4. 2.16 the Angirases declare that their ancestors made sacrifices “…"