"In fact, the insight of the double effect doctrine is not remotely theologic. As Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, himself a frequent utilitarian critic of relying on intent, observed, "even a dog distinguishes between being stumbled over and being kicked." Of course, the question remains why should we, as a secular matter, care more about consequences that are intended versus those that are not? What wisdom, if any, lies behind this distinction? Justice Holmes' homespun illustration suggests the beginnings of an explanation. To kick a dog intentionally- to choose to hurt the animal- says something about the kicker, his or her way of interacting with animals and, perhaps, human beings- in short, it tells us at least something about the kicker's character and beliefs, about who the kicker is. By contrast, as Holmes seemed to recognize, watching a person trip over the dog tells us far less about who that person is or about the person's character or beliefs."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesJustices of the Supreme Court of the United StatesLawyers from the United StatesPeople from DenverGeorgetown Preparatory School alumni
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p. 55
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Neil_Gorsuch
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Neil Gorsuch
37 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Neil Gorsuch →
Related Quotes
"The self-defining nature of intended actions can be illustrated by the case, developed earlier in this chapter, of th…"
"The morally defining nature of intentions can be further illustrated by any number of choices we make in daily living…"
"In contrast to unintended consequences, intended acts are always within our control, subjects of our free will and ch…"
"Much public debate over assisted suicide and euthanasia both in the U.S. and abroad has rested on the implicit premis…"
"Of course, the movement for legalizing assisted suicide and euthanasia is at least in part the result of a culture in…"
"Of course, trying to separate the sacred from the secular can be a tricky business—perhaps especially for a civil cou…"
"It seems well past time to reconsider our sweeping UPL [Unauthorized Practice of Law] prohibitions. The fact is nonla…"
"I immediately lost what breath I had left. And I am not embarrassed to admit that I couldn’t see the rest of the way …"
"Courage has been essential to the rule of law in this country from the beginning. The Declaration of Independence its…"
"This overweening addiction to the courtroom as the place to debate social policy is bad for the country and bad for t…"