"But instead of Cantor admitting the independence or at least the relative independence of the Indians, i.e. the independence of their geometry from the Greeks, he expresses himself extremely tortuous, even he did not give up his Heron hypothesis by hiding it behind the doubtful question at the end, whether there are not at the end in the Sulbasutras relatively modern insertions."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
19th-century German mathematiciansUniversity of Göttingen alumniGerman historians of mathematics20th-century German mathematiciansHeidelberg University alumni
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Simon, Max. Geschichte der Mathematik im Altertum. Berlin 1909.in The Sulbasutras and the 'Pythagoras Theorem' (Simon 1909: 138-139):
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Moritz_Cantor
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Moritz Cantor
Moritz Benedikt Cantor (23 August 1829 – 10 April 1920) was a German historian of mathematics.
10 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Moritz Cantor →
Related Quotes
"For Egypt, in my opinion, the one fact of experience was sufficient that there was a right-angled triangle 4, 3, 5. T…"
"[…] should it […] boil down to the fact that individual parts of the Sulbasutras are relatively modern interpolations?"
"Therefore, we do not doubt for a moment that Pythagoras’ stay in Egypt, that the lessons he received from the priests…"
"So much appears certain to us, that Pythagoras could have been in Babylon."
"Some of the things, which belong particularly to the history of mathematics, we will not refrain from attributing to …"
"Pythagoras remarked, we think, that 9+16=25. When he made this under all circumstances interesting remark, he already…"
"Pythagoras, so we tried to prove, certainly acquired mathematical knowledge in Egypt, perhaps in the Euphrates countr…"
"It is hardly conceivable that these writers [Aryabhata, Brahmagupta, Bhaskaracharya etc.], should have been unacquain…"
"Cantor concludes that Indian geometry and Greek geometry, especially of Heron, are related; and the only question is,…"
"Practise ever truth and uprightness till the cold grave, and deviate not a finger’s breadth from God’s ways! Then wil…"