"Despite their differences, both Hayek and Rawls reject the idea that economic rewards should reflect what people deserve. In doing so, they acknowledge that they are challenging conventional wisdom. The notion that justice means giving people what they deserve seems deeply embedded in untutored common opinion. Rawls notes the “tendency for common sense to suppose” that income and wealth should be distributed according to moral desert, and Hayek admits that his renunciation of merit “may appear at first so strange and even shocking” that he must “ask the reader to suspend judgment” until he can explain. But even as free-market liberalism and welfare state liberalism set the terms of public discourse over the past half century, they did not dislodge the widely held conviction that what people earn should reflect what they deserve. To the contrary, during those decades, meritocratic attitudes toward success tightened their hold, even as mobility stalled and inequality deepened."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesJews from the United StatesPeople from MinneapolisHarvard University faculty
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chap. 5. Success Ethics
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Michael_Sandel
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Michael Sandel
34 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Michael Sandel →
Related Quotes
"But if political philosophy is unrealizable in one sense, it is unavoidable in another."
"Political philosophy seems often to reside at a distance from the world. Principles are one thing, politics another, …"
"This liberalism says, in other words, that what makes the just society just is not the telos or purpose or end at whi…"
"Unlike the liberty of the early republic, the modern version permits — in fact even requires — concentrated power."
"Admittedly, the tendency to bracket substantive moral questions makes it difficult to argue for toleration in the lan…"
"A public philosophy is an elusive thing, for it is constantly before our eyes. It forms the often unreflective backgr…"
"The idea that freedom consists in our capacity to choose our ends finds prominent expression in our politics and law.…"
"Central to republican theory is the idea that liberty depends on sharing in self-government. This idea is not by itse…"
"It is sometimes thought that liberal principles can be justified by a simple version of moral relativism. Government …"
"Political philosophy seems often to reside at a distance from the world. Principles are one thing, politics another, …"