"Philosophy establishes itself as a discourse by opposition to the authority of received opinion, especially the opinions sedimented as cult and as law. Philosophy puts into question the authority of what has been handed down. It is not just that there is a critique of philosophic authorities; rather, philosophy appears to be characterized by rejection of intellectual authority as such. How is philosophy to distinguish, then, a permissible authority from those many impermissible authorities which it must reject if it is to survive? Perhaps it would be better to avoid the quandary altogether by dismissing authority in order to consider only the "content" of the claims under consideration, regardless of their pretensions. The dismissal fails for at least two reasons. The first is that there are no claims in philosophic texts that are wholly free at least from the implicit constructions of authority. If criticism takes only the content, then it ends up with something other than the texts that have constituted the discourse of philosophy. There is no Platonic "theory of Forms" dissociable from the Platonic pedagogy, that is, from the teaching authority of the Platonic Socrates. The second reason for not being able to dismiss authority altogether is that the very criticism that wants to look only at contents will impose itself as an authority in its choice of procedure. One will still have authority, but an authority that refuses to raise any question about authority. Perhaps the question about legitimate authority could be avoided, again, by replying that the obvious criterion for claims in philosophy is the truth. The assumption here is that access to the truth is had entirely apart from the authority of philosophical traditions. Yet it is a biographical fact that one is brought into philosophy by education. First principles are learned most often not by simple observation or by the natural light of reason, but under the tutelage of some authoritative tradition."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Mark_D._Jordan
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Mark D. Jordan
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Mark D. Jordan →
Related Quotes
"The end of philosophic education, on many ancient views, is not a body of propositions to be measured against an equa…"
"Aristippus is credited with having said that those who stop short of philosophy in the preparatory studies are like P…"
"Once one learns how to speak a language, the authority of the language has fulfilled its aim, but is not thereby over…"
"Historiography cannot, by itself, answer the question about the criterion for pedagogical authenticity. So much is ob…"
"The claim of philosophy to be about the whole can be secured only if the many "ordinary" languages in the whole can b…"
"Socratic trustworthiness depends upon devices of irony, both spoken and acted. … The irony of words prevents Socrates…"
"Porphyry is right to suggest that Plotinus' teaching "voice" has about it something particular (idios), speaking as i…"
"Academic writing excuses itself from rhetorical care in the selfless service of some precise truth—and then deforms o…"
"One reason that Christian theology is so detached from larger intellectual or artistic movements is that it has not s…"
"In December 1976, the Dade County Metro Commission passed unanimously on first reading an ordinance banning discrimin…"