"The greatest danger I see in the many-worlds/one-Hilbert-space point of view (beside the ridiculous silliness of it all) is the degree to which it is a dead end. The degree to which it is morally bankrupt. Charlie, by thinking that he has taken some of the anthropocentrism out of the picture, has actually emptied the world of all content. Beyond that though, I think, many-worlds empties the world of content in a way that’s even worse than classical determinism. Let me explain. In my mind, both completely deterministic ontologies and completely indeterministic ones are equally unpalatable. This is because, in both, all our consciousnesses, all our great works of literature, everything that we know, even the coffee maker in my kitchen, are but dangling appendages, illusions. In the first case, the only truth is the Great Initial Condition. In the second, it is the great “I Am That I Am.” But many-worlds compounds that trouble in a far worse fashion by stripping away even those small corners of mystery. It is a world in which anything goes, and everything does. What could be more empty than that?"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Christopher A. Fuchs, Letters to Herb Bernstein, “Epiphenomena Chez Dyer”, 02 August 1999, published in Coming of Age with Quantum Information: Notes on a Paulian Idea (2011)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Many-worlds interpretation
24 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Many-worlds interpretation →
Related Quotes
"MWI is not some crazy speculative idea that runs afoul of Occam’s razor. On the contrary, MWI really is just the “obv…"
"If the MWI were supported by some sound science, we would have to deal with it – and to do so with more seriousness t…"
"The “many worlds interpretation” seems to me an extravagant, and above all an extravagantly vague, hypothesis. I coul…"
"Yes, I have strong feelings against it, but I have to qualify that by saying that in this particular Einstein-Podolsk…"
"It's extremely bizarre, and for me that would already be enough reason to dislike it. The idea that there are all tho…"
"He explains that the multiple worlds are not an add-on to the theory but instead are simply what happens naturally wh…"
"The conclusion, therefore, is that multiple worlds automatically occur in quantum mechanics. They are an inevitable p…"
"Fortunately, a minority of physicists, myself included, likewise side unequivocally with realism, by adopting Hugh Ev…"
"In fact the physicists have no good point of view. Somebody mumbled something about a many-world picture, and that ma…"
"To call MWI an interpretation is like talking about dinosaurs as an 'interpretation' of fossil records."