"It is disappointing to have to say that at present there seems to be no hope of estimating objectively and with a useful degree of precision how long an originally homogeneous Indo-European language would have taken to develop into derivative groups or languages which diverged as much as Greek, Sanskrit and Hittite did when the earliest texts in them were composed. Some linguists seem to think that they can make intuitive judgements about the minimum time which a particular phonetic or other change in a language would have taken. But the results of intuition when applied to estimating the minimum time in which a group of cognate languages or dialects would have differentiated to an observed extent vary so much that no useful deductions can be made from them. I sympathize with archaeologists and other prehistorians who are not primarily linguists over this. Linguists are unable to provide the information which would be most useful."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Crossland, Ronald. 1972. "Recent Reappraisal of Evidence for the Chronology of the Differentiation of Indo-European." In Acta of the 2nd International Colloquium on Aegean Prehistory (46-55). Athens: Ministry of Culture and Science. Crossland (1972) quoted in Bryant, E. F. (2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture : the Indo-Aryan migration debate. Oxford University Press. chapter 12
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Linguistic_reconstruction
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Linguistic reconstruction
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Linguistic reconstruction →
Related Quotes
"[I]t can be very difficult to determine whether a word truly is inherited from the Proto-Indo-European vocabulary or …"
"We must not make the mistake of confusing our methods, and the results flowing from them, with the facts; we must not…"
"No reputable linguist pretends that Proto-Indo-European reconstructions represent a reality, and the unpronounceabili…"
"Hermann goes even further: complete forms cannot be reconstructed at all, only single sounds, and even these are mean…"
"Comparative grammar is in reality radically incapable of discriminating between divergent kinship… and convergent kin…"
"Examples could be multiplied to show that language, long held to be the main, if not the sole, differentiating mark o…"
"A question therefore arises: what is the relevance of archaeological material if any sort of assemblage present at th…"
"Linguists cannot associate an archaeological culture with words, syntax, and grammar, and archaeologists cannot make …"
"Contemporary methodologies, linguistic or archaeological, for determining the spoken language of a remote archaeologi…"
"In the context of a renewed fashion of relating archaeology, culture, and language it is well to remember that neithe…"