"In an interview at Catholic University last week, Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas said what he’s clearly been thinking for the past 30 years: Supreme Court precedents don’t matter, and he’s making things up as he goes along to fulfill his own political agenda. He didn’t say it in that way, of course. People would have noticed that. Instead, he couched his self-serving philosophy in legal jargon that will fly under the radar of most people, including journalists. Here’s what he said: “At some point we need to think about what we’re doing with stare decisis.… [I]t’s not some sort of talismanic deal where you can just say ‘stare decisis’ and not think, turn off the brain, right?” To translate: “Stare decisis” is a foundational legal principle in this country and all countries that follow a “common law” system. What it means, in simple terms, is that prior judicial rulings govern future judicial rulings. If a court rules, for instance, that “gay people have the same basic rights as everyone else in this country, including the right to marry other people,” then that ruling is supposed to govern all future cases concerning the rights of gay people. Thomas, apparently, doesn’t agree. Instead of respecting stare decisis and precedent, he is saying that older cases shouldn’t have the power to control newer ones. For Thomas, just because courts ruled that LGBTQ people should have rights in the past, including the right to marry, doesn’t mean he feels compelled to rule that they should keep them."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Elie Mystal, Thomas Admits That He’s Coming for Our Rights", The Nation, 2 October 2025
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/LGBT_in_the_United_States
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
LGBT in the United States
22 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by LGBT in the United States →
Related Quotes
"And so the question arises: How does America address its homophobic past as it moves forward into a more tolerant fut…"
"Embittered by the unexpected defeat, Briggs, who once described gay men as women trapped in men's bodies," called San…"
"What's happening now is a wholesale repudiation of the 1990s move to eject gay people from the American family, writ …"
"The 1990s are over. Newt Gingrich, who stepped down as House Speaker after the Republicans performed poorly at the po…"
"The origins of the two political movements at the heart of America's culture war are as humble as they are contempora…"
"The "silent majority," Viguerie determined, was as motivated by a constellation of family issues, exemplified by gay …"
"The most bitter showdown came in California in 1978, when state senator and gubernatorial candidate John Briggs of Fu…"
"American society is already hospitable to passive and effeminate males. What they need is affirmation as men so that …"
"While there are many people who accept the romantic propaganda about male homosexual existence, the life of tricks an…"
"America is a different country now, a dozen years on from what Frank Rich described in 1999 as "[t]he homophobic epid…"