"Suppose it were so; so much, then, the better, as we should not want then to show that the soul could become torpid and recover; because, then, it would never be torpid> and, consequently, would be immortal, which is all we want to prove. And this opinion, I believe, is that of the majority of thinking persons, but unfortunately mixed up with divers principles, not orthodox, some of them acknowledging a soul m man, but not in any other living being; others going one step further, and admitting a soul in other animals too, but imagining that it is a different sort of soul to that of man, instead of considering that one soul is similar to another, and that all the difference between one individual and another is corporeal,—the organization of the body or brain, by its variations, alone producing, it would appear, all the varieties of character, without any variation of soul, to which conclusion we are led by the fact that we cannot produce any thought or feeling in the mind but through the instrumentality of the body; and it seems only on the bodily organs, and physical agents upon them, that every perfection and defect of mind depends; an idiot, a philosopher, and a mouse, appearing to have quite similar souls, the difference only being in the organs of sense, which act upon the souls, and are in themselves different. No person can deny that different sensations are produced by bodily causes; why, then, must we look to something else to produce them—namely, to variations of the soul ? Bodily causes are enough, and we are not driven to seek for further causes. The soul is always, if I am correct, the same. It does not grow, it does not decay; and is as perfect in an infant as In a man—the improvement and growth of mind being only of the corporeal part."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Jews from the United KingdomInventorsActivists from EnglandNon-fiction authors from EnglandAnimal rights activists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Elucidations on Elements of Morality, pp. 252–253
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Lewis_Gompertz
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Lewis Gompertz
(1783/4 – 2 December 1861) was an English philosopher, writer, inventor, and social reformer. He was best known for his pioneering advocacy of the moral consideration of animals, early veganism, and opposition to animal exploitation. A founding member of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (later the RSPCA), he later established the Animals' Friend Society to promote a more comprehensive ethical stance toward animals. His 1824 treatise, Moral Inquiries on the Situation of Man an
48 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Lewis Gompertz →
Related Quotes
"Y: What are your opinions concerning the propriety of using silk? Z: I disapprove of the act of depriving the living …"
"The force of custom or habits even proverbial; and accordingly we take advantage of the magnified representation in w…"
"Are [animals] not furnished with most feelings similar to our own? They indisputably evince in an eminent degree most…"
"It has been generally, but not always, the custom of naturalists to degrade the powers of dumb animals into mere inst…"
"In order to admire the goodness of God with the greatest force, we should endeavour to reach in imagination the impro…"
"[T]his seems to be still the age of infancy, and baby-like do we cry. This is all made for me! The land and the ocean…"
"[E]very animal has more right to the use of its own body than others have to use it."
"Suppose...we reflect on the building of London Bridge, we cannot then help admiring the genius and assiduity of man. …"
"[H]owever the state of man may be above that of other animals, if the superiority be owing to his being differently s…"
"And though I cannot conceive how any person can shut his eyes to the general state of misery throughout the universe,…"