"Compare how Britannica and Wikipedia introduce the traditional system of Indian medicine called Ayerveda. Britannica is respectful. Wikipedia has no fewer than four dismissive epithets in the first paragraph: "quackery," "pseudoscientific," "protoscience," and "unscientific."... Not long ago, this article would have been regarded as a deep offense against multiculturalism. ... It is not the role of an encyclopedia to tell people what to think or to cast aspersions on entire cultures. ... Wikipedia should make *no* claims on its own behalf about what is (effective) medicine; that is not the role of an encyclopedia. It can repeat research on that though. ... You assume that you can detect what "modern medicine," or other scientific or scholarly work, really is, i.e., whether it actually passes muster of the scientific method. ... If the systems of peer review is screwed up, you can't. Nor if medical research is tainted by filthy lucre from Big Pharma. The world is considerably more complicated than the silly children at Wikipedia think it is. Britannica at least understands that much."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Businesspeople from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesNon-fiction authors from the United StatesBloggers from the United StatesAgnostics from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Larry Sanger. Tweet on Twitter (September 3, 2020). [https://twitter.com/lsanger/status/1301662041401430016 [https://twitter.com/lsanger/status/1301706909528076290
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Larry_Sanger
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Larry Sanger
31 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Larry Sanger →
Related Quotes
"I know Wikipedia is very cool. A lot of people do not think so, but of course they are wrong."
"If the project was lucky enough to have a writer or two well-informed about some specialized subject, and if their wo…"
"A few of the project's participants can be, not to put a nice word on it, pretty nasty. And this is tolerated."
"Wikipedia lacks the habit or tradition of respect for expertise. As a community, far from being elitist (which would,…"
"Citizendium is based on the failings and unreliability of Wikipedia."
"Wikipedia will be small, disreputable, and unimportant compared to CZ in a few more years. Uh, ;-)"
"I thought that the evidence against your claims about me would shame you into changing your behavior. But, five years…"
"I have learned that the people probably angriest at Wikipedia are Hindus... I am happy to point out the obvious, name…"
"There is a massive irony in the fact that Wikipedia is so extremely biased: it was started by someone who cares unusu…"
"Suppose that, as is perfectly possible, Wikipedia continues producing articles at a rate of 1,000 per month. In seven…"