"But no. That was analogy rather than homology. What in the humanities they would call a heroic simile, if he understood the term, or a metaphor, or some other kind of literary analogy. And analogies were mostly meaningless—a matter of phenotype rather than genotype (to use another analogy). Most, of poetry and literature, really all the humanities, not to mention the social sciences, were phenotypic as far as Sax could tell. They added up to a huge compendium of meaningless analogies, which did not help to explain things, but only distorted perception of them. A kind of continuous conceptual drunkenness, one might say. Sax himself much preferred exactitude and explanatory power, and why not? If it was 200 Kelvin outside why not say so, rather than talk about witches’ tits and the like, hauling the whole great baggage of the ignorant past along to obscure every encounter with sensory reality? It was absurd. So, okay, there was no such thing as cultural polyploidy. There was just a determinate historical situation, the consequence of all that had come before—the decisions made, the results spreading out over the planet in complete disarray, evolving, or one should say developing, without a plan. Planless. In that regard there was a similarity between history and evolution, both of them being matters of contingency and accident, as well as patterns of development. But the differences, particularly in time scales, were so gross as to make that similarity nothing more than analogy again. No, better to concentrate on homologies, those structural similarities that indicated actual physical relationships, that really explained something. This of course took one back into science."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Science fiction authors from the United StatesNovelists from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesSocialists from the United StatesPeople from Chicago
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chapter 4, “The Scientist as Hero” (p. 185)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Kim_Stanley_Robinson
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Kim Stanley Robinson
147 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Kim Stanley Robinson →
Related Quotes
"In games there are rules, but in life the rules keep changing."
"They were so ignorant! Young men and women, educated very carefully to be apolitical, to be technicians who thought t…"
"For of course it was impossible that she was doing it all without cause. That was the nature of power; when you had i…"
"It was a mistake to speak one’s mind at any time, unless it perfectly matched your political purpose; and it never di…"
"And then she was tired of talk again, tired of its uselessness. It had never been any more than it was now: whispers …"
"Friendship was just diplomacy by other means, after all."
"No—living on after the memory died was mere farce, pointless and awful."
"Maya was very insistent that they learn their math well. “You’re getting a horrible education,” she would say, shakin…"
"Master and slave wear the yoke together. Anarchy is the only true freedom."
"Some of them defined ideology as an imaginary relationship to a real situation."