"This is the "apophatic" tradition, in which nothing about God can be put into words. Armstrong firmly recommends silence, having written at least 15 books on the topic. Words such as "God" have to be seen as symbols, not names, but any word falls short of describing what it symbolises, and will always be inadequate, contradictory, metaphorical or allegorical. The mystery at the heart of religious practice is ineffable, unapproachable by reason and by language. Silence is its truest expression. The right kind of silence, of course, not that of the pothead or inebriate. The religious state is exactly that of Alice after hearing the nonsense poem "Jabberwocky": "Somehow it seems to fill my head with ideas — only I don't exactly know what they are." … Armstrong is not presenting a case for God in the sense most people in our idolatrous world would think of it. The ordinary man or woman in the pew or on the prayer mat probably thinks of God as a kind of large version of themselves with mysterious powers and a rather nasty temper. That is the vice of theory again, and as long as they think like that, ordinary folk are not truly religious, whatever they profess. By contrast, Armstrong promises that her kinds of practice will make us better, wiser, more forgiving, loving, courageous, selfless, hopeful and just. Who can be against that? The odd thing is that the book presupposes that such desirable improvements are the same thing as an increase in understanding — only a kind of understanding that has no describable content. It is beyond words, yet is nevertheless to be described in terms of awareness and truth."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Non-fiction authors from EnglandWomen authors from EnglandFeminists from EnglandWomen academics from EnglandChristian nuns
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Simon Blackburn, reviewing The Case for God : What Religion Really Means in "All quiet on the God front" in The Guardian (4 July 2009)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Karen_Armstrong
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Karen Armstrong
44 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Karen Armstrong →
Related Quotes
"He was simply a nadhir, a messenger with a warning, and should approach the Quraysh humbly, avoid provocation, and be…"
"Muslims respect the pacifist message of Jesus (even though the Qu'ran points out that Christians can be very belliger…"
"Far from being the father of jihad, Mohammad was a peacemaker, who risked his life and nearly lost the loyalty of his…"
"Deeds that seemed unimportant at the time would prove to have been momentous; a tiny act of selfishness and unkindnes…"
"The word qur’an means “recitation.” It was not designed for private perusal, but like most scriptures, it was meant t…"
"Monotheism is essentially inimical to tribalism: it demands that a people unite in a single community."
"The new radical Islam is not simply inspired by the hatred of the West, however. Nor is it in any sense a homogeneous…"
"All truly creative thought is in some sense intuitive; it demands a leap forward into the dark world of uncreated rea…"
"He was decisive and wholehearted in everything he did, so intent non the task at hand that he never looked over his s…"
"There are some forms of religion that must make God weep. There are some forms of religion that are bad, just as ther…"