"The main point, which would perhaps be unnecessary to labour if it were not so controversial and if it had not been denied in important respects by some quite unlikely people, is that the theory of evolution has been a major, even decisive, contributor to the process of undermining prescientific supernaturalistic metaphysical views and replacing them with the naturalistic metaphysics assumed by most contemporary philosophers. The question is not whether evolution and a particular religious tradition are logically consistent. Provided the religious tradition avoids factual claims, as Gould’s conception of distinct magisteria forces them to do by fiat and as sensible theologians have been increasingly willing to do for centuries, they are consistent because they do not speak on the same subjects. But it is nevertheless the case that science and religion speak for radically different conceptions of the universe. And as the conception fostered by the former has become more compelling, so that promoted by the latter has become less tenable. Science does not contradict religion; but it makes it increasingly improbable that religious discourse has any subject matter."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
University of Cambridge alumniPhilosophers from EnglandUniversity of Oxford facultyUniversity of Oxford alumniStanford University faculty
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chapter 4, “Human Origins and the Decline of Theism” (p. 60)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Dupr%C3%A9
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
John Dupré
13 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by John Dupré →
Related Quotes
"Empiricism provides the standard to which beliefs should answer. If we are capable of finding out what kind of world …"
"Obviously enough, we cannot decide what evolution entails without a fairly sharp conception of what it is."
"Faith is, I suppose, a rough synonym for belief, with an additional connotation that this belief is not grounded on a…"
"The main point I want to make in this chapter is that prior to the development of a convincing theory of evolution th…"
"I should mention the possibility that there are moral rather than empirical reasons that favor religious belief. It i…"
"Religious difference, arguably, remains the most effective basis for defending boundaries between them and us, and th…"
"One commonly held ideal of a possible good life is one spent in adoration of or service to the Supreme Being. It is h…"
"Whatever the unique features of humans may be, there are realms of behaviour for which the similarities between ourse…"
"The limits of a creature’s consciousness are closely related to its particular set of capacities. As I shall elaborat…"
"Darwin and his intellectual descendants have provided us with fundamental insight into the nature of the world we liv…"