"Jarrige (1973) complains of the tendency of lumping everything not typically Harappan under the rubric of the Jhukar culture, "a problem which is further complicated when, by attempting to harmonize the archaeological data with philological arguments, people have developed the habit of attributing to the Jhukar culture all discoveries amenable of offering some correlation with the Iranian world and Central Asia" (263). Jarrige goes on to consider whether there was a disruption of sedentary urban life in the Indus Valley and a sudden drop in agricultural productivity of that area accompanied by a shift to seminomadic pastoralism with evidence of warfare—in short, all of the features that would ideally accompany an intrusion of Indo-Aryan nomads. As the excavator of Pirak, the only well-preserved second millennium B.C.E. site from the area (which he dates from 1700 to 700 B.C.E.), Jarrige (1985) finds a "town" of some size with "elaborate architecture" and evidence of a more intense level of irrigation and cultivation than occurred in the third millennium B.C.E.: "Just the opposite of that which has been presumed on the basis of negative evidence" (46)."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Bryant, E. F. (2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture : the Indo-Aryan migration debate. Oxford University Press.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Jhukar_phase
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Jhukar phase
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Jhukar phase →
Related Quotes
"Jarrige (1983), in contrast, had long since pointed out that there were chronological problems with correlating the s…"
"Even the supposedly alien cultures like those labelled as Jhukar and Cemetery H are regional transformations... from …"
"[Mackay and Piggott] overemphasized this single culture-constituent and treated the Jhukar pottery as signifying an a…"
"It is thus absolutely clear that: (i) there was an occupational and cultural continuity from the Mature Harappan time…"
"From the foregoing analysis of the data from Mohenjo-daro, Jukar, Amri and Chanhudaro it would be seen that the Harap…"
"A report by Time Magazine (dated 30th June 1980) read, “In the worst massacre, in the village of Mandai, the tribals …"
"Now compare this with the attitude of the BBC during the Kargil war. Most of us foreign correspondents know by now th…"
"Ex-Mandai MLA recounted, Manoranjan Debbarma. “Children were spiked to death and wombs of pregnant women were ripped …"
"Major R. Rajamani, the commander of the Indian Army unit that reached Mandai on 9th June 1980, compared the brutality…"
"During the winter of 1998/99, Pakistanis had stealthily occupied several Himalayan mountain peaks on the Indian side.…"