"The problematic therefore becomes obvious: Which of the two peoples are the Indo-Iranians, the Andronovo people or the BMAC people, keeping in mind that their material cultures, as well as their economic systems, were radically different? Both answers have, of course, been proposed, each with acceptable arguments, and we will not even attempt to sum up the highly technical debates—ongoing and nowhere near resolution—between the proponents of the BMAC option52 (incidentally, this is where Adolphe Pictet located the original Cradle in 1859) and proponents of the steppic option.53 In reality, the archaeological arguments needed to certify the “Indo-Iranian-ness” of a given site are highly debatable.54 Reference is made to the existence of a “fire cult,” to the crushing of plants to obtain an inebriating drink (the soma of the Indians and the haoma of the Iranians—of which we know nothing), the exposure and defleshing of corpses, and, in contrast, their cremation, etc. However, these activities do not leave unequivocal and specific traces within the archaeological record. Cremation occurs no earlier on the steppes than in the BMAC area, and, in any case, it is not a particularly strong marker of ethnicity, regardless of the period in question.55 The iconography found on luxury goods associated with the BMAC does not share any themes with the ancient Indo-Iranian texts. We encounter a goddess, a bird of prey hero, a dragon, and an ibex-god, which evoke both a shared Eurasian background and clear influences from Elam; only a small number of silver vessels bear scenes that, according to Henri-Paul Francfort, might potentially find comparisons in Indo-Iranian mythologies.56"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Jean-Paul_Demoule
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Jean-Paul Demoule
28 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Jean-Paul Demoule →
Related Quotes
"We do not find any evidence for the diffusion of the entire material culture of the steppes to those regions where hi…"
"While no one would dream of questioning the resemblances between the various so-called Indo-European languages, the c…"
"The past and present exploitation by nationalist and extremist movements of the canonical Indo-European model of an o…"
"The model of diffusion of “archaeological cultures,” each corresponding to a given “people,” is both naturalist and d…"
"The idea of a single, localized, original Homeland (Urheimat) which was the cradle of the original People is just one…"
"We will now turn our attention to the two other principal hypotheses, both migrationist and both with a long history …"
"It is presumptuous to say the least to claim that the migratory routes traveled by the Indo-Europeans from their orig…"
"This controversial scholar, the first translator of Darwin and by extension the first promoter of “social Darwinism” …"
"There is a degree of coherence when, in the context of the Indo-European question, such robust biological racism is a…"
"The 'problem' is primarily in the head of Indo-Europeanists: It is a problem of interpretative logic and ideology. We…"