"He has always written to be read. He is always as concerned with the quality of his prose as he is with the quality of his argument or the precision of his evidence. In intention alone, such literary concern marks him out from the mass of practising academic historians, and the results of his endeavours mark him out even more clearly. His writing is, for pace, vigour and flow, unrivalled among contemporary historians and sometimes it is held to be too vivid. His figures of speech are not always appreciated by the profession: when he wrote, for instance, of Walpole's attempt to muzzle the youthful Chatham, "As well might he attempt to stop a hurricane with a hairnet", there were not a few reviewers who tut-tutted at the extravagance of the idea and its expression, but fortunately most have welcomed a writer who can present the product of massive scholarship elegantly and compactly and vividly. For his work can convey an unusual sense of intellectual excitement, and its polish and panache make him one of the most readable historians... He is a man to read for the larger scale and the developing vision. He is an historian to read for the changing relationship between political allies and rivals, for the battle between moral scruple and tactical skill in political factions, for the narrative curve of a politician's career, of the unfolding of a man's character in the face of opportunity, triumph, setback or defeat."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Historians from EnglandNon-fiction authors from EnglandPeople from LeicesterFellows of the British Academy
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
J. H. Plumb
Sir John (Jack) Harold Plumb FBA (20 August 1911 – 21 October 2001) was a British historian, known for his books on British 18th-century history. He wrote over thirty books.
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by J. H. Plumb →
Related Quotes
"Men write history for many reasons; to try to understand the forces which impel mankind along its strange course; to …"
"His [Winston Churchill's] violent disagreement with Neville Chamberlain did not spring solely from thwarted ambition …"
"For many years, as a gloomy exercise, I used to look for British cars on the streets of New York and the best that I …"
"Some years ago, Sir John Plumb, aware of the threat both to the general mind and to the survival of his profession th…"
"I once wrote that I knew no one else who could at the same time master the technical problems of conveying the sweep …"
"If boldly conceived, thoughtfully researched and elegantly written popular history is once again enjoying an extraord…"
"In 1950 Plumb was confident enough to write for "The Pelican History of England" his justly famous masterpiece of com…"
"Creative energy is one of Professor Plumb's most obvious gifts – another is his sense of reality. No other historian …"
"Professor Plumb is outstanding among contemporary historians in fighting this diminished scope of his chosen discipli…"
"In Robert Walpole's life he has found the exemplar of that need for political stability without which social stabilit…"