"These errors are deliberate and motivated, given their context and arrangement, and this St. Thomas entry in the Encyclopaedia has been written by a Catholic scholar who not only subscribes to the apostle’s alleged South Indian adventure, but wishes to place the Mylapore tale over that of the Malabar tradition. He does this by mixing the North Indian legend, represented by the Acts, with the South Indian fable that the Portuguese left in Mylapore, to promote his particular South Indian masala view. He gets away with the deception because nobody has read the Acts of Thomas and studied its references to the kings Gundaphorus and Misdaeus-Mazdai, and the execution of Judas Thomas on a mountain that contained an ancient royal tomb. On 19 September 1996 we decided to call the Encyclopaedia Britannica’s bluff and sent a letter, with a copy of this book (second revised edition), to the Encyclopaedia’s editor-in-chief in Chicago pointing out the errors in their St. Thomas entry. The editorial division representative Anthony G. Craine replied to us on 18 October 1996. He wrote, "We have received your book, and we have subsequently reviewed our coverage of Saint Thomas. While the Saint Thomas article that appears in the current printing of the Encyclopaedia Britannica differs slightly from the 1984 article to which you refer in your book, the current article does convey the same basic information. We have concluded that the portion of the article that refers to Thomas’ later life places too much emphasis on the unlikely scenario of his traveling to, and being martyred in India (emphasis added). We have referred this information to the appropriate editor so that the article can be revised in future printings of Britannica. We appreciate your bringing this matter to our attention.""
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ishwar_Sharan
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Ishwar Sharan
104 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Ishwar Sharan →
Related Quotes
"Both Rufinus and Socrates would have known the Greek version of the Acts which was made immediately after the Syriac …"
"This writer once had the misfortune of meeting The Hindu editor, N. Ram. He arrived one morning in 1992 on our ashram…"
"While the belief that Thomas settled in South India came about as an honest mistake, the claim that he was martyred b…"
"The famous English historian Arnold Toynbee observed that the mission and death of St. Thomas in India was legendary …"
"The revelation that the tomb of St. Peter is a fake will not come as a surprise to Europeans. They know better than a…"
"The Jesuit Bollandist Peeters and Maurice Winternitz, Professor of Indian Philology and Ethnology at the German Unive…"
"This statement is patently absurd in the face of the evidence of the Acts itself. Mylapore has never been “a desert c…"
"There is simply nothing Indian, much less South Indian, in the setting and ambiance of the Acts of Thomas. All intern…"
"C.B. Firth could have included the testimony of Origen’s teacher, the Greek missionary theologian Clement of Alexandr…"
"But Clement, Origen and Eusebius are not the only early Christian scholars to say that St. Thomas went to Parthia. Th…"