"Now, Irfan Habib’s seemingly strongest piece of evidence (not for the temple’s non-existence, of course, but at least for the untrustworthiness of some pro-temple spokesmen) turned out to be false... During the demolition on 6 December 1992, many Hindu artefacts had turned up, albeit in less than desirable circumstances from an archaeological viewpoint... Among the first findings during the demolition was the Vishnu Hari inscription, dating from the mid-11th century Rajput temple, which the Babri Masjid masons had placed between the outer and inner wall. Several Babri historians dismissed the inscription as fake, as of much later date, or as actually brought by the Kar Sevaks during the demolition itself. Prof. Irfan Habib, in a combine with Dr. Jahnawi Roy and Dr. Pushpa Prasad, dismissed this inscription as stolen from the Lucknow Museum and to be nothing other than the Treta ka Thakur inscription. The curator kept this inscription under lock, but after some trying, Kishore Kunal, author of another Ayodhya book (Ayodhya Revisited, 2016), could finally gain access to it and publish a photograph. What had been suspected all along, turns out to be true: Prof. Habib, who must have known both inscriptions, has told a blatant lie. Both inscriptions exist and are different. Here they have been neatly juxtaposed on p.104-5. Yet, none of the three scholars has “responded to the publication of the photograph of the Treta ka Thakur inscription, which falsifies the arguments they have been persistently advocating for over two decades.”"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Meenakshi Jain, quoted and cited in Elst Koenraad, Epitaph for the Ayodhya affair, 2017, quoting Meenakshi Jain,
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Irfan_Habib
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Irfan Habib
23 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Irfan Habib →
Related Quotes
"In one of his theses Marx said: 'Philosophers have so far interpreted the world. The point is to change it.' Marxism …"
"It is inherent in the unity of past and present that Marxist historiography must continuously turn to fresh aspects t…"
"To begin with, the new conquerors and rulers…were of a different faith (Islam) from that of their predecessors… their…"
"“…the population during the Mughal period did not remain stable though the compound rate of growth, 0.14% per annum, …"
"While medieval Islamic literature referred to Hindus as 'infidels' and denounced polytheism and image worship, there …"
"The pressure of new circumstances led initially to large-scale slave-trading and the emergence of slave labour during…"
""The evidence for such enslavement is there for all to see. So economically important was it that the success of mili…"
"The publication of Dr. Tasneem Ahmad’s translation is a notable contribution to the National celebration of the 450th…"
"But it seems likely... that Sarasvati/Harakhvati was the name for the Helmand. Otherwise it is difficult to understan…"
"Without undue modesty, we can say we know more about India’s past than Marx did."