"Media Piracy's core thesis is simple: people in the poor world don't pay for software, games, music and movies because these goods cost too much. Whereas a DVD here might cost you an hour's wage, the same DVD in a poor country could cost a day's work, or a week's, or even more. In poor markets where legitimate media costs the same (in relative terms) as it does in rich markets, the amount of licit purchasing is about the same. But that's not what the media companies say they believe. In their official narrative – bolstered by a long line of studies with undocumented methodologies and assumptions – is that poor countries simply lack a "culture of copyright" that can be reinforced through education and enforcement. Karganis and co have much to say on this score. They document the way that the airwaves and newspapers in poor countries are dominated by the official, Hollywood view of piracy, presented uncritically and at length. The message is even integrated into the school curriculum through official teaching units produced by American entertainment conglomerates and given to teachers to be delivered verbatim to their students. On the enforcement side, entertainment companies often secure a kind of rough, streamlined justice that allows them to race to the head of the justice line, pushing past criminal and civil cases of much larger magnitude. They get their own police forces tasked to them, and their own special high-grade punishments that treat offences against them as inherently graver than offences against local firms and people."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Cory Doctorow, “Why poor countries lead the world in piracy”, The Guardian, (3 May 2011).
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Internet_file_sharing
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Internet file sharing
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Internet file sharing →
Related Quotes
"I am speechless about the idea of putting music fans in jail for downloading music. It is wrong to illegally download…"
"If they succeed in destroying our books or even making many of them inaccessible, there will be a chilling effect on …"
"Media piracy has been called "a global scourge," "an international plague," and "nirvana for criminals," but it is pr…"
"[D]omestic piracy may well impose losses on specific industrial sectors, but these are not losses to the larger natio…"
"P2P continues to account for a high percentage of total bandwidth utilization in most poarts of the world, and infrin…"
"Recent IIPA reports cite rates of music piracy in excess of 90% in China, India, Mexico, and Brazil. Less and less of…"
"Child pornography is great. Politicians do not understand file sharing, but they understand child pornography, and th…"
"If there's anyone out there involved in illegal movie piracy ... don't do it. Take a good look at these people. These…"
"There is no justice in following unjust laws. It’s time to come into the light and, in the grand tradition of civil d…"
"Napster affected rock CD sales disproportionately when it first came out in the late ’90s, because rock was what a lo…"