"The astronomical lore in Vedic literature provides elements of an absolute chronology in a consistent way. Moreover, it is encouraging to note that the astronomical evidence is free of contradictions. There would be a real problem if the astronomical indications had put the Upanishads earlier than the Rg-Veda, or Kalidasa earlier than the Brahmanas, but that is not the case: the astronomical evidence is consistent. Inconsistency would give support to the predictable objection that these astronomical references are but poetical fabulation without any scientific contents. However, the facts are just the opposite. To the extent that there are astronomical indications in the Vedas, these form a consistent set of data detailing an absolute chronology for Vedic literature in full agreement with the known relative chronology of the different texts of this literature. They contradict the hypothesis that the Vedas were composed after an invasion in ca. 1500 BC. Not one of the astronomical data in Vedic literature confirms the AIT-based low Vedic chronology.... Indeed, the whole corpus of astronomical evidence is hard to reconcile with the AIT, and has been standing as a growing challenge to the AIT for two centuries, i.e. from before the AIT had even been thought up. A convincing refutation would require an alternative but consistent (philogically as well as astronomically sound) interpretation of the existing astronomical indications that brings Vedic literature down to a much later age. But so far, such a reading of those text passages has not been offered. There is as yet no astronomical information which puts the Vedas at an AIT-compatible date."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Elst, Koenraad (2007). Asterisk in bharopiyasthan: Minor writings on the Aryan invasion debate.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Indian_astronomy
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Indian astronomy
26 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Indian astronomy →
Related Quotes
"Sage Maruts, may we be the drivers of the car of riches ful I of life that have been given by you. O Maruts, let that…"
"That Hindu astronomical lore about ancient times cannot be based on later back-calculation, was also argued by Playfa…"
"The Hindu religion is the only one of the world’s great faiths dedicated to the idea that the Cosmos itself undergoes…"
"“The observations on which the astronomy of India is founded, were made more than three thousand years before the Chr…"
"All this at least on the assumption that Playfair’s, Bailly’s and Rajaram’s claims about the Hindu astronomical table…"
"Since the 1780s, Western researchers (Playfair, Bailly, Jacobi) have noticed data in Indian astronomy, both astronomi…"
"“By adding the hymn counts of the ten books of the Rig-Veda in different combinations, we obtain numbers that are fac…"
"If we exclude the possibility of every astronomical notice in Vedic literature being a record of ancient tradition, w…"
"Whither by day depart the constellations that shine at night, set high in heaven above us? Varuṇa's holy laws remain …"
"The Hindu systems of astronomy are by far the oldest, and that from which the Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, and even the…"