"So one crazy analogy to how my morality might turn out to work, and the big point here is I don't know how my morality works, is we have a painting and the painting is very beautiful. There is some crap on the painting. Would I like the crap cleaned up? Yes, very much. That's like the suffering that's in the world today. Then there is making more of the painting, that's just a strange function. My utility with the size of the painting, it's just like a strange and complicated function. It may go up in any kind of reasonable term that I can actually foresee, but flatten out, at some point. So to see the world as like a painting and my utility of it is that, I think that is somewhat of an analogy to how my morality may work, that it's not like there is this linear multiplier and the multiplier is one thing or another thing. It's: starting to talk about billions of future generations is just like going so far outside of where my morality has ever been stress-tested. I don't how it would respond. I actually suspect that it would flatten out the same way as with the painting."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Businesspeople from the United StatesPhilanthropists from the United StatesHarvard University alumni
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
In a conversation with Luke Muehlhauser and Eliezer Yudkowsky, January 2014; part of this is quoted by Carl Shulman in "Population ethics and inaccessible populations"
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Holden_Karnofsky
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Holden Karnofsky
16 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Holden Karnofsky →
Related Quotes
"When I look at large foundations making multimillion-dollar decisions while keeping their data and reasoning "confide…"
"The issue, it seems to me, is that many people think of giving the same way they think of eating broccoli: they feel …"
"But on the other hand, there are a couple of dimensions where Harvard] alumni have much higher opinions of themselves…"
"I wanted to get my partner Daniela a special and valuable engagement present, but we had long agreed that a diamond r…"
"I update negatively on people who mislead (including expressing great confidence while being wrong, and especially in…"
"I have more pet peeves than anyone else I know, and one of the very biggest ones is what I call flakes: people who sa…"
"I model the world as having most of the impact from extreme cases, 'home-runs'. I think that's true in business, scie…"
"I could tell you about my strengths and weaknesses. I'm creative and intelligent and able to rock the boat and do thi…"
"Regarding (b) ["checking boxes I want to check for considering myself a personally moral/ethical person, which is rel…"
"My sense is that factory farms do a great deal of damage to the world that isn't included in the prices of their prod…"