"The "exhaustion method" (the term "exhaust" appears first in , 1647) was the Platonic school's answer to Zeno. It avoided the pitfalls of the infinitesimals by simply discarding them... by reducing problems... to... formal logic only. ...This indirect method... the standard Greek and Renaissance mode of strict proof in area and volume computation was quite rigorous, ...It had the disadvantage that the result... must be known in advance, so that the mathematician finds it first by another less rigorous and more tentative method. ...a letter from Archimedes to Eratosthenes... described a nonrigorous but fertile way of finding results ...known as the "Method." It has been suggested... that it represented a school of mathematical reasoning competing with Eudoxus... In Democritus' school, according to the theory of Luria, the notion of a "geometrical atom" was introduced. ...several mathematicians before Newton, notably Kepler, used essentially the same conceptions... our modern limit conceptions have made it possible to build this... into a theory as rigorous as... "exhaustion"... The advantage of the "atom method" over the "exhaustion method" was that it facilitated the finding of new results. Antiquity had thus the choice between a rigorous but relatively sterile, and a loosely-founded but far more fertile method. ...in practically all classical texts the first [the exhaustion] method was used. This... may be connected with the fact that mathematics had become a hobby of the leisure class which was based on slavery, indifferent to invention, and interested in contemplation. It may also be a reflection of the victory of Platonic idealism over Democritian materialism in the realm of mathematical philosophy."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
, A Concise History of Mathematics (1948) with a reference to S. Luria, "Die Infinitesimaltheorie der antiken Atomisten" Quellen und Studien B 2 (1932) pp.106-185.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/History_of_calculus
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
History of calculus
146 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by History of calculus →
Related Quotes
"In Sorbière's day, European thinkers and intellectuals of widely divergent religious and political affiliations campa…"
"On the one side were ranged the forces of hierarchy and order—Jesuits, Hobbesians, French Royal Courtiers, and High C…"
"[Joseph-Louis Lagrange's] lectures on differential calculus form the basis of his Theorie des fonctions analytiques w…"
"Nothing is easier... than to fit a deceptively smooth curve to the discontinuities of mathematical invention. Everyth…"
"Fermat applied his method of tangents to many difficult problems. The method has the form of the now-standard method …"
"Descartes' method of finding tangents and normals... was not a happy inspiration. It was quickly superseded by that o…"
"Archimedes was the earliest thinker to develop the apparatus of an infinite series with a finite limit ...starting on…"
"The fundamental definitions of the calculus, those of the derivative and integral, are now so clearly stated in textb…"
"The precision of statement and the facility of application which the rules of the calculus early afforded were in a m…"
"Nothing in Descartes' work led directly to Leibniz's calculus, but Descartes' discoveries in mathematics were certain…"