"It is probable that no mathematician has ever equalled Newton in his command of the processes of classical geometry. But his adoption of it for purposes of demonstration appears to have arisen from the fact that the infinitesimal calculus was then unknown to most of his readers, and had he used it to demonstrate results which were in themselves opposed to the prevalent philosophy of the time the controversy would have first turned on the validity of the methods employed. Newton therefore cast the demonstrations of the Principia into a geometrical shape which, if somewhat longer, could at any rate be made intelligible to all mathematical students and of which the methods were above suspicion. ...in Newton's time and for nearly a century afterwards the differential and fluxional calculus were not fully developed and did not possess the same superiority over the method he adopted which they do now. The effect of his confining himself rigorously to classical geometry and elementary algebra, and of his refusal to make any use even of analytical geometry and of trigonometry is that the Principia is written in a language which is archaic (even if not unfamiliar) to us. The subject of optics lends itself more readily to a geometrical treatment, and thus his demonstrations of theorems in that subject are not very different to those still used. The adoption of geometrical methods in the Principia for purposes of demonstration does not indicate a preference on Newton's part for geometry over analysis as an instrument of research, for it is now known that Newton used the fluxional calculus in the first instance in finding some of the theorems (especially those towards the end of book I. and in book II.), and then gave geometrical proofs of his results. This translation of numerous theorems of great complexity into the language of the geometry of Archimedes and Apollonius is I suppose one of the most wonderful intellectual feats which was ever performed."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/History_of_calculus
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
History of calculus
146 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by History of calculus →
Related Quotes
"In Sorbière's day, European thinkers and intellectuals of widely divergent religious and political affiliations campa…"
"On the one side were ranged the forces of hierarchy and order—Jesuits, Hobbesians, French Royal Courtiers, and High C…"
"[Joseph-Louis Lagrange's] lectures on differential calculus form the basis of his Theorie des fonctions analytiques w…"
"Nothing is easier... than to fit a deceptively smooth curve to the discontinuities of mathematical invention. Everyth…"
"Fermat applied his method of tangents to many difficult problems. The method has the form of the now-standard method …"
"Descartes' method of finding tangents and normals... was not a happy inspiration. It was quickly superseded by that o…"
"Archimedes was the earliest thinker to develop the apparatus of an infinite series with a finite limit ...starting on…"
"The fundamental definitions of the calculus, those of the derivative and integral, are now so clearly stated in textb…"
"The precision of statement and the facility of application which the rules of the calculus early afforded were in a m…"
"Nothing in Descartes' work led directly to Leibniz's calculus, but Descartes' discoveries in mathematics were certain…"