"Another feature of Alexandrian algebra is the absence of any explicit deductive structure. The various types of numbers... were not defined. Nor was there any axiomatic basis on which a deductive structure could be erected. The work of Heron, Nichomachus, and Diophantus, and of Archimedes as far as his arithmetic is concerned, reads like the procedural texts of the Egyptians and Babylonians... The deductive, orderly proof of Euclid and Apollonius, and of Archimedes' geometry is gone. The problems are inductive in spirit, in that they show methods for concrete problems that presumably apply to general classes whose extent is not specified. In view of the fact that as a consequence of the work of the classical Greeks mathematical results were supposed to be derived deductively from an explicit axiomatic basis, the emergence of an independent arithmetic and algebra with no logical structure of its own raised what became one of the great problems of the history of mathematics. This approach to arithmetic and algebra is the clearest indication of the Egyptian and Babylonian influences... Though the Alexandrian Greek algebraists did not seem to be concerned about this deficiency... it did trouble deeply the European mathematicians."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Morris Kline, Mathematical Thought from Ancient to Modern Times (1972) p.144
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/History_of_algebra
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
History of algebra
112 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by History of algebra →
Related Quotes
"All the modern higher mathematics is based on a calculus of operations, on laws of thought. All mathematics, from the…"
"The precision of statement and the facility of application which the rules of the calculus early afforded were in a m…"
"The most influential mathematics textbook of ancient times is easily named, for the Elements of Euclid has set the pa…"
"We think only through the medium of words.—Languages are true analytical methods.—Algebra, which is adapted to its pu…"
"As regards algebra, the early Arabs failed to adopt either the Diophantine or the Hindu notations. An examination of …"
"Admitting the Hindu and Alexandrian authors [such as Diophantus], to be nearly equally ancient, it must be conceded i…"
"al-Khwārizmī “not having taken algebra from the Greeks,. . . must have either invented it himself, or taken it from t…"
"My specific... object has been to contain, within the prescribed limits, the whole of the student's course, from the …"
"The following Treatise... has been endeavoured to make the theory of limits, or ultimate ratios... the sole foundatio…"
"I have decided first to consider the majority of the authors who up to now have written about [algebra], so that I ca…"