"Given what we have seen of Marxist historians even in this brief book, the brazen-faced distortions – to the point of falsehood – do not surprise me.... That these eminences were in control of journals, of history congresses, and university departments, had another immediate consequence: no one dared question their work. They hadn’t to explain their ‘theses’, they could serve up any concoction as ‘evidence’. In regurgitating the same assertions, they convinced themselves that they were being consistent; in arriving at the same reductionist explanations for diverse phenomena, phenomena millennia apart, they convinced themselves that they were fortifying the theory. In fact, all they were doing was repeating themselves. There was nothing new to be learnt as it had all been explained before! In a word, unquestioned, above being challenged, they slipped into shoddiness, and thus stagnation – Jha’s Address is an illustration of the kind of drivel that came to pass as scholarship."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Arun Shourie : Eminent Historians: Their Technology, Their Line, Their Fraud, 1998 (2014), HarperCollins
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Historiography_of_India
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Historiography of India
87 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Historiography of India →
Related Quotes
"The idea of continuity of the Indian civilization does not suit the beliefs of this group of people. There is a serio…"
"Many of those who read history at Delhi in the mid-1970s and later, still bear the ugly scars inflicted by the though…"
"The medieval period of Indian history has been a source of propaganda for historians with ideological predilections. …"
"For those unfamiliar with modern Indian history: the Marxists, already pushy for acquiring as much power in the insti…"
"Most importantly, for the ancient period, Indian Marxist and other anti-Hindu historians posit a massive conflict (be…"
"For her class of people, a “professional historian” is a historian with academic status. They are very status-conscio…"
"But the negationists are not satisfied with seeing their own version of the facts being repeated in more and more boo…"
"What the BJP government claims to offer, what all scholarly historians want, and what is loathed by the Marxists who …"
"The facts concerning the persecution of Hindus in the pre-modern age were a matter of consensus until recently. For c…"
"One must beware of falling into a kind of uncritical Indological McCarthyism towards those open to reconsidering the …"