"Hayek cannot see how, in a planned state, groups can settle their differences over the course to be followed when, the state is to undertake various business projects. He pretends that in this case it is necessary to leave it to "the discretion of the judge or authority in question" to decide what is "fair and reasonable." This again is hypothetical. The solution depends on how the law of the plan is constructed, and the ability and state of mind of the negotiators in parliament, in the courts, and in regulatory bodies such as the Tariff Commission, the Interstate Commerce Commission, the Federal Communications Commission, and the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are solving problems and building up important experience. But principally it depends on nationwide debate conducted over the course of years, assisted by the sifted results of scientific research and experience. The plan, such as it is, emerges from the majority; and only that emerges from the majority which the majority can thereafter operate. That is the answer to Hayekian obscurantism."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chap. 4 : The Rule of Law is Rule of Hayek
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Herman_Finer
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Herman Finer
Herman Finer (February 24, 1898 – March 4, 1969) was a Jewish Romanian-born British political scientist and Fabian socialist.
16 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Herman Finer →
Related Quotes
"Reaction has been waiting yearningly for this message, for someone to smite democracy hip and thigh. It eases the con…"
"Government is the instrument for the exchange of one kind of benefit among persons and groups for others; the exchang…"
"Most human beings like enjoyment without employment. Most human beings like the services of government while they cla…"
"If the champions of an economic and political delusion were its only victims, we could with a little charity leave th…"
"No one intends to "plan" or "collectivize" or "socialize" all economic activities, but many do wish to administer sol…"
"Professor Hayek's history is not history. Especially before the nineteenth century, but quite plentifully since the s…"
"Hayek's unscrupulous travesty of the democratic process of securing legislation (for that is the first basis of any g…"
"Hayek's assumption is that political power is neither limited in scope, restricted in authority, responsible in opera…"
"To get competition among firms with large capital — how is that possible? Only by setting up competitors who have int…"
"Hitler was not a socialist. He was a nationalist and a racialist; and in Mein Kampf himself tells how he designed to …"