"In his essay on Repressive Tolerance...Marcuse argues that the tolerance of the advanced industrial democracies is a deceit... Freedom of speech is not an overriding good, for to allow freedom of speech in the present society is to assist in the propagation of error, and "the telos of tolerance is truth." The truth is carried by the revolutionary minorities and their intellectual spokesmen, such as Marcuse, and the majority have to be liberated by being re-educated into the truth by this minority, who are entitled to suppress rival and harmful opinions. This is perhaps the most dangerous of all Marcuse's doctrines, for not only is what he asserts false, but his is a doctrine which if it were widely held would be an effective barrier to any rational progress and liberation... What, then, are the true connections between tolerance, rationality, and liberation? The telos of tolerance is not truth but rationality. Certainly we value rationality because it is by rational methods that we discover truth; but a man may be rational who holds many false beliefs, and a man may have true beliefs and yet be irrational. What is crucial is that the former has the possibility of progressing toward truth, while the second not only has no grounds for asserting what he believes, even though it is true, but is continually liable to acquire false beliefs. What is it to be rational? It is a necessary condition of rationality that a man shall formulate his beliefs in such a way that it is clear what evidence would be evidence against them and that he shall lay himself open to criticism and refutation in the light of any possible extreme. But to foreclose on tolerance is precisely to cut oneself off from such criticism and refutation. It is to gravely endanger one’s own rationality by not admitting one's own fallibility."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesAcademics from GermanyImmigrants to the United StatesSociologists from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Alasdair MacIntyre, Marcuse (1970), pp. 89-91
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Herbert_Marcuse
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Herbert Marcuse
1898 – 1979
deutsch-amerikanischer Soziologe und Philosoph
169 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Herbert Marcuse →
Related Quotes
"In the most advanced areas of this civilization, the social controls have been introjected to the point where even in…"
"Reason and Revolution, Hegel and the Rise of Social Theory, Herbert Marcuse, London Routledge & Kegan Paul LTD 2nd ed…"
"Understanding finds nothing but itself when it seeks the essence behind the appearance of things. ‘It is manifest tha…"
"As the German idealists saw it, the French Revolution not only abolished feudal absolutism, replacing it with the eco…"
"The world of immediate experience—the world in which we find ourselves living—must be comprehended, transformed, even…"
"In conditions of private property … “life-activity” stands in the service of property instead of property standing th…"
"We hope that the analysis offered here will demonstrate that Hegel’s basic concepts are hostile to the tendencies tha…"
"Bourgeois political economy … never gets to see man who is its real subject. It disregards the essence of man and his…"
"If man has learned to see and know what really is, he will act in accordance with truth, Epistemology is in itself et…"
"Man is a thinking being. His reason enables him to recognize his own potentialities and those of his world. He is thu…"