"The very possibility of the science of mathematics seems an insoluble contradiction. If this science is deductive only in appearance, whence does it derive that perfect rigor no one dreams of doubting? If, on the contrary, all the propositions it enunciates can be deduced one from another by the rules of formal logic, why is not mathematics reduced to an immense tautology? The syllogism can teach us nothing essentially new, and, if everything is to spring from the principle of identity, everything should be capable of being reduced to it. Shall we then admit that the enunciations of all those theorems which fill so many volumes are nothing but devious ways of saying A is A! ...Does the mathematical method proceed from particular to the general, and, if so, how can it be called deductive? ...If we refuse to admit these consequences, it must be conceded that mathematical reasoning has of itself a sort of creative virtue and consequently differs from a syllogism."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from FrancePhilosophers from FranceMathematicians from FrancePhysicists from FranceEngineers from France
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Ch. I: On the Nature of Mathematical Reasoning (1905) Tr. George Bruce Halstead
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Henri_Poincar%C3%A9
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Henri Poincaré
90 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Henri Poincaré →
Related Quotes
"We do not have and cannot have any means of discovering whether or not we are carried along in a uniform motion of tr…"
"Tout le monde y croit cependant, me disait un jour M. Lippmann, car les expérimentateurs s'imaginent que c'est un thé…"
"Le savant digne de ce nom, le géomètre surtout, éprouve en face de son œuvre la même impression que l'artiste ; sa jo…"
"La tâche de l'éducateur est de faire repasser l'esprit de l'enfant par où a passé celui de ses pères, en passant rapi…"
"C'est même des hypothèses simples qu'il faut le plus se défier, parce que ce sont celles qui ont le plus de chances d…"
"Que l'on cherche à se représenter la figure formée par ces deux courbes et leurs intersections en nombre infini dont …"
"Comme nous ne pouvons pas donner de l'énergie une définition générale, le principe de la conservation de l'énergie si…"
"What is objective must be common to many minds and consequently transmissible from one to the other, and as this tran…"
"There is no science apart from the general. It may even be said that the very object of the exact sciences is to spar…"
"La pensée ne doit jamais se soumettre, ni à un dogme, ni à un parti, ni à une passion, ni à un intérêt, ni à une idée…"