"Recent hypotheses connecting the Oxus civilization with the Indo- Iranians or the Indo-Aryans are of two kinds: the first consider the Oxus civilization as an emanation of the Indo-Iranians / Indo-Aryans (Sarianidi, Hiebert); the second hold that newcomers from the steppes succeeded the Oxus civilization (Kuzmina) or took possession of it (Parpola, Mallory). This wide uncertainty, which may appear surprising, is due to the fact that no trace of invasion is noticed on the ground, no cultural transformation is marked by the presence of archaeological material whose origin could be attributed to peripheral regions. Expressions like “elite dominance” or “infiltration,” despite their great evocative power, are nothing but rhetorical devices. They do not manage to mask our present inability to account for a supposed historical phenomenon. [...] In neither of the two regions, steppes and oases, do we find an archaeological material that could be indisputably attributed to Indo-Iranians, Indo- Aryans, or Iranians."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Henri-Paul Francfort, “Oxus Civilization, or BMAC, Indo-Iranians and Indo-Aryans” in Âryas, Aryens et Iraniens en Asie Centrale, by Gérard Fussman, Jean Kellens, Henri- Paul Francfort & Xavier Tremblay (Paris: Collège de France & Institut de civilisation indienne, 2005, p. 262.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Henri-Paul_Francfort
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Henri-Paul Francfort
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Henri-Paul Francfort →
Related Quotes
"Apart from the time-space expectations, there is not much in the archaeological material that could be taken as tags …"
"In short, apart from the time-space expectations, there is nothing in the archaeological material that could be taken…"
"The question of identifying archaeological remains of Indo-European populations in Central Asia has been one of the m…"
"Consequently, in current migratory hypotheses, in the same way that the Oxus Civilization disappears upon contact wit…"
"Francfort (1989) stresses this point: "Nothing allows us to dismiss the possibility that the Andronovians of Tazabagj…"
"Although Champollion was an avowed revolutionary and an enthusiastic Bonapartist, one of his earliest discoveries dis…"
"... many Europeans today go to Pelasgians, who are no less distant or savage, and for equally slight gains, to discov…"
"When at the present day we approach such subjects we are met at every turn by the danger of falling into platitude an…"
"Responsible AI is artificial intelligence that must be designed responsibly by humans in a way that respects human va…"
"Like biologists, who have been concerned about ethics for years and have banned human cloning, for example, IT profes…"