"It is only with this prelude that the Declaration of 1776 proclaims the right to revolution. The people do not have an indiscriminate or uncontrolled right to establish or to abolish governments. They have a right to abolish only those governments that become "destructive of these ends". "These ends" refers to the security of equal natural rights. It is only for the sake of security of these rights that legitimate governments are instituted, or that governments may be altered or abolished. And governments are legitimate only insofar as their "just powers" are derived "from the consent of the governed". All of the foregoing is omitted from South Carolina's declaration, for obvious reasons. In no sense could it have been said that the slaves in South Carolina were governed by powers derived from their consent. Nor could it be said that South Carolina was separating itself from the government of the Union because that government had become destructive of the ends for which it was established. South Carolina in 1860 had an entirely different idea of what the ends of government ought to be from that of 1776 or 1787. That difference can be summed up in the difference between holding slavery to be an evil, if possibly a necessary evil, and holding it to be a positive good."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesEducators from the United StatesHistorians from the United StatesJews from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p. 231
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Harry_V._Jaffa
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Harry V. Jaffa
Harry Victor Jaffa (7 October 1918 – 10 January 2015) was an American historian, writer, and collegiate professor from New York City, known for his writings on the American Civil War.
171 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Harry V. Jaffa →
Related Quotes
"[T]he generation of the Founding Fathers, who certainly knew the story of Noah and his sons, nonetheless believed in …"
"That one man can run faster than another is no reason to prevent the latter from entering the race. Indeed, until the…"
"[S]laves are never referred to in the Constitution as anything but 'persons', a characterization that is perfectly ne…"
"This remarkable address conveys, more than any other contemporary document, not only the soul of the Confederacy but …"
"According to Davis it did not require a Galileo or a Harvey (or a Darwin) to discover the natural inferiority of the …"
"In 1860 Senator Wilson, like Lincoln, could not ask for recognition of more than the black man's natural rights. But …"
"And it’s important to understand the sequence of events, and the ideas that accompanied that sequence of events that …"
"[S]lavery existed among the Americans largely because of the action of the crown. For the king to have been complicit…"
"The paradox of calling the same human beings persons and property brings the cause of the Civil War into the sharpest…"
"South Carolina cites, loosely, but with substantial accuracy, some of the language of the original Declaration. That …"