"If we have only to classify a finite number of objects, it is easy to preserve these classifications without change. If the number of objects is indefinite, ...[i.e.,] if we are constantly liable to find new and unforeseen objects springing up, it may happen that the appearance of a new object will oblige us to modify the classification, and it is thus that we are exposed to antinomies. There is no actual infinity. The Cantorians forgot this, and so fell into contradiction. It is true that Cantorism has been useful, but that was when it was applied to a real problem, whose terms were clearly defined, and then it was possible to advance without danger. Like the Cantorians, the logicians have forgotten the fact, and they have met with the same difficulties. ...[B]elief in an actual infinity is essential in the Russellian logic, and this... distinguishes it from the Hilbertian logic. Hilbert takes the... view of extension... to avoid the Cantorian antimonies. Russell takes the... view of comprehension... to regard the infinite as actual. And we have not only infinite classes; when we pass from the genus to the species... the number of conditions is still infinite, for they generally express that the object... is in... relation with all the objects of an infinite class. But all this is ."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Henri Poincaré, Science et Méthode (1908) Tr. Francis Maitland, Science and Method (1914)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Georg_Cantor
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Related Quotes
"The totality of all alephs cannot be conceived as a determinate, well-defined, and also a finished set. This is the p…"
"Er ist aber in Kopenhagen geboren, von israelitischen Eltern, die der dortigen portugisischen Judengemeinde."
"The potential infinite means nothing other than an undetermined, variable quantity, always remaining finite, which ha…"
"In re mathematica ars proponendi quaestionem pluris facienda est quam solvendi."
"I realize that in this undertaking I place myself in a certain opposition to views widely held concerning the mathema…"
"Had Mittag-Leffler had his way, I should have to wait until the year 1984, which to me seemed too great a demand!"
"The old and oft-repeated proposition "Totum est majus sua parte" [the whole is larger than the part] may be applied w…"
"There is no doubt that we cannot do without variable quantities in the sense of the potential infinite. But from this…"
"In order for there to be a variable quantity in some mathematical study, the domain of its variability must strictly …"
"Every transfinite consistent multiplicity, that is, every transfinite set, must have a definite aleph as its cardinal…"