"When I started writing [Citizens], I thought the revolution of 1789 then goes on the skids and turns into the Terror of 1793. But I became more and more alarmed by what happened in 1789, and more and more bleak about what it is we are supposed to be celebrating. It dawned on me that no sooner had the Declaration of the Rights of Man been signed than a law was passed which allowed opening of mail, stopped freedom of movement and had a brutal attitude to who was a patriot and who was not. Then there was the violence. It was not the fact of decapitation so much as the way these people self-consciously understood what you could do with violence, the way violence could construct allegiances. I'm not saying no good came of the revolution. There was the definition of a citizen with equal rights before the law, the emancipation of the Jews and black slaves – these were intrinsically noble. But the way the revolution enacts these doesn't accidentally produce violence. It necessarily produces violence. And if you look at the landscape of France in 1799 with Bonapartist military dictatorship, the balance is unhappy rather than happy."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Simon Schama, interview with Bryan Appleyard, quoted in Bryan Appleyard, 'The revolutionary historian', The Times (13 May 1989), p. 31
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/French_Revolution
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
French Revolution
59 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by French Revolution →
Related Quotes
"Since the outbreak of the French Revolution, the world has been moving with ever increasing speed towards a new confl…"
"You can lock the door upon them, but they burst open their shaky lattices and call out over the house-tops so that me…"
"Louis XVI, after confessing that despotism was useless, even to make men happy by compulsion, appealed to the nation …"
"It was the French and not the American Revolution that set the world on fire, and it was consequently from the course…"
"[T]wo parties diametrically opposed by their system and their plan for the public administration... I am ready to bel…"
"The grandeur of the Revolution in the eyes of those who had witnessed it, or had received its tradition from actors i…"
"Since the great French Revolution all colour has been gradually dying out of the male costume, until we have got redu…"
"The French had shown themselves the ablest architects of ruin that had hitherto existed in the world. In that very sh…"
"What was done in France was a wild attempt to methodize anarchy; to perpetuate and fix disorder. That it was a foul, …"
"The essential result of the French revolution was to establish the doctrine of popular sovereignty as the foundation …"