"Generally, the death of a judge, in what seem to be mysterious circumstances, while presiding over a case against the second most powerful person in the country, and the closest associate of the head of the government, would be make prime-time television in a democracy. Similarly, the allegations of corruption against the family of the same person would have garnered media attention. But recent events in India prove otherwise. [...] But the more damaging development has been the role of the mainstream media in the face of government attempts to muzzle it. Just as in the judge story, there was silence about the corruption story in the media. Even when there was coverage, it was more about the defamation case filed by Mr. Shah rather than the merits of story itself. The rare television channel that has sometimes been critical of the Modi government and faced its wrath for doing so, succumbed, pulling down reportage about the Shah story. This is an extraordinary level of submissiveness displayed by the media. This must also be read in the context of the largest democracy’s abysmal ranking in the World . Last year, India ranked 133 out of 18 countries. And this year, it has declined to 136. Recently, the main mode of against journalists doing investigative stories has been through Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs), like the one filed by Mr. Shah. Journalists face severe challenges, including physical violence and threat to life, in carrying out their work. [...] So, the emerging “manufacture of consent” in favor of the ruling government does not happen only through active participation, or on criticism by the media, but also as a result of the egregious threats that the media personnel face."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Nissim Mannathukkaren on the death of Brijgopal Harkishan Loya, Modi government and the muzzling of the Indian media, 3 December 2017, '
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Freedom_of_expression_in_India
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Freedom of expression in India
38 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Freedom of expression in India →
Related Quotes
"If some people do not like a representation of art, there are other ways to counter it. I never support violent attac…"
"The emphasis has been twofold: That the state knows, the state is right, the state must be privileged, and that citiz…"
"Every ban and censorship hurt. But banishment hurts the most. Banishment took away the ground from beneath my feet. W…"
"While all governments, in varying degrees, try to muzzle free speech or physically intimidate journalists, what is ra…"
"The [Arya Samajs'] defiant stand against Islam was increasingly reaping the whirlwind... A pamphlet of the local Sana…"
"Muslim leaders and Stalinist historians were raising a howl about Hindu chauvinism when it came to the notice of Arun…"
"After the Babri structure came down, Shri N. Ram thundered at a conference in Delhi that the print media owed it to t…"
"There are definitions of hate speech based on the Khan Market consensus as to who should be allowed to speak and who …"
"Jokes making fun of Mr. Modi, or Facebook posts of lay citizens, and films criticizing his government are met with po…"
"The situation in India is far worse than it is in other countries. The French Marxist scholar Maxime Rodinson's biogr…"