"I think we can defend the view that there are two different sorts of moral gap, an ‘affection gap’ and a ‘performance gap’. The affection gap is that non-human animals do not have what Duns Scotus calls ‘the affection for justice’, which is a pull towards what is good in itself, regardless of any relation to us. The performance gap is that we do not find in ourselves the innate capacity to live consistently by the affection for justice by merely human devices. ... De Waal says that the doctrine of original sin has been refuted and that we are not sinfully self-centered but ‘we are driven to empathize with others in an automated, often unconditional fashion. We genuinely care about others, wanting to see them happy and healthy regardless of what immediate good this may do for us.’ However, he agrees that we do not find in non-human animals morality itself, though we do find kin selection, so-called ‘reciprocal altruism’, and social control. This admits the affection gap. He also agrees that human beings, despite formal protestations to the contrary and despite our innate goodness, put self and its kin first, then the ingroup, and the idea of being moral towards individuals from other groups is very recent and very fragile. As far as I can see, this is the performance gap."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the NetherlandsNon-fiction authors from the NetherlandsPsychologists from the NetherlandsBiologists from the NetherlandsPrimatologists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
John E. Hare, “Evolutionary Theory and Theological Ethics,” Studies in Christian Ethics, vol. 25, no. 2 (2012), p. 251
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Frans_de_Waal
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Frans de Waal
19 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Frans de Waal →
Related Quotes
"I think if we study the primates, we notice that a lot of these things that we value in ourselves, such as human mora…"
"I first saw them in 1978. At the time, I knew a lot about chimps, because I had been studying them. I saw the bonobos…"
"At the time, I was interested in reconciliation after fights, and I wanted to know how bonobos did it compared to chi…"
"If you look at human society, it is very easy, of course, to compare our warfare and territoriality with the chimpanz…"
"It is true that the chimpanzee is dominance-oriented, violent, territorial. But it's also cooperative in many ways, a…"
"I would say there are people in this world who like hierarchies, they like to keep people in their place, they like l…"
"Imagine that we didn't know the chimpanzee, that all we knew were those bonobos who have sex all the time and are pea…"
"To endow animals with human emotions has long been a scientific taboo. But if we do not, we risk missing something fu…"
"I've argued that many of what philosophers call moral sentiments can be seen in other species. In chimpanzees, gorill…"
"The possibility that empathy resides in parts of the brain so ancient that we share them with rats should give pause …"