"I don't know what it means to express confidence that judges will do what they ought to do, after having read the foreign law. My problem is I don't know what they ought to do. What is it that they ought to do? You have to ask yourselves, Why is it that foreign law would be relevant to what an American judge does when he interprets -- interprets, not writes -- I mean, the Founders used a lot of foreign law. If you read the Federalist Papers, it's full of discussions of the Swiss system, German system. It's full of that. It is very useful in devising a constitution. But why is it useful in interpreting one?"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Antonin Scalia, Discussion Between U.S. Supreme Court Justices Antonin Scalia and Stephen Breyer -- AU Washington College of Law (January 13, 2005).
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Foreign_law
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Foreign law
19 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Foreign law →
Related Quotes
"I have no power to follow the authorities cited to me from the United States if by so doing I were to contravene the …"
"Do you think things outside the United States cannot be relevant to an understanding of how to apply the American Con…"
"But that's the document, I'm interpreting that document. And to think that one might learn from other countries in ho…"
"If you have that philosophy, obviously foreign law is irrelevant with one exception: Old English law, because phrases…"
"The sentences of foreign Courts have always some degree of regard paid to them by the Courts of justice here: and it …"
"The Judge has not organs to know and to deal with the text of the foreign law, and therefore requires the assistance …"
"To learn what the laws of a country are, is not the work of a day even in pacific times, and to persons accustomed to…"
"It is every day's practice with us to decide cases which turn upon the laws of foreign countries, or the laws adminis…"
"Unless Parliament has conferred upon the Court that power in language which is unmistakable, the Court is not to assu…"
"We should treat with great respect the opinion of eminent American lawyers on points which arise before us, but the p…"