"Thus defined, it should be apparent that "involuntary servitude" includes coerced pregnancy. The pregnant woman may not serve at the fetus’ “command”-it is the state that, by outlawing abortion, supplies the element of coercion-but she is serving involuntarily for the fetus’ "benefit", and this is what the Court has said that the amendment forbids. If citizens may not be forced to surrender control of their persons and services, then women’s persons may not be invaded and their services may not be coerced for the benefit of fetuses. It is as simple as that. The injury inflicted on women by forced motherhood is lesser in degree than that inflicted on blacks by antebellum slavery, since it is temporary and involves less than total control over the body, but it the same “kind” of injury. When abortion is outlawed, a woman who does not want to carry her pregnancy to term must serve the fetus, and that servitude is involuntary. Some of those to whom I have made this argument have responded less with skepticism than with horror. They consider it a libel on motherhood, which, far from being like slavery, is an exhilarating, awe-inspiring, and joyous experience. It may not be out of place, therefore, to address this concern at the outset. The objection gathers whatever force it has by focusing on the experience of women who “want” to be mothers. The thirteenth amendment, however, does not apply to them. The servitude it prohibits is “involuntary”. The distinction between wanted and unwanted pregnancy is like the difference between wanted and unwanted sex. Can rape be defended on the grounds that sex is an exhilarating, awe-inspiring, joyous experience? Do arguments that focus on the degrading and violative aspects of rape constitute a libel of sex? Plantation slavery obviously cannot be justified on the grounds that many people find gardening deeply satisfying, but this objection is really no better than that."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp.487-488
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Forced_pregnancy
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Forced pregnancy
30 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Forced pregnancy →
Related Quotes
"The baby is a gift, given by life itself. But to be a gift a thing must be freely given and freely received. A gift c…"
"Laws that prevent people from making their own decisions about whether to continue a pregnancy or have an abortion am…"
"Our fight will continue until we can put an end to laws that force people to carry pregnancies against their will and…"
"In 1993 the United Nations (UN) Commission on Human Rights (replaced in 2006 by the UN Human Rights Council) declared…"
"The women who bear children and the medical experts who assist them testify that pregnancy and childbearing are indee…"
"Forced pregnancy is defined as when a woman or girl becomes pregnant without having sought or desired it, and abortio…"
"The Commission on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women Committee and the Committee on the Rights of the Ch…"
"Black women’s sexual subordination and forced pregnancies were foundational to slavery. If cotton was euphemistically…"
"The fall out is also reaching the children of the kidnapped brides. The Duke University study found that ethnic babie…"
"Enforced childbirth is slavery[.]"