"It was impossible, in Hamilton's view, for a nation to act towards other nations as a man of warm feelings would act towards his neighbours. A nation cannot afford to indulge itself in hatred or affection, magnanimity or revenge. In deciding upon its course of action, sentiment is as irrelevant a consideration as malice, and wars of chivalry are as iniquitous as wars of religion. The statesman who bends to an emotional outburst of public opinion as richly deserves to be shot as a general who surrenders a city out of compassion for the inhabitants. The stern test of the righteousness of a war is the permanent security of the state. A government which goes knight-erranting out of sympathy for foreign nations is like a trustee who subscribes to charities out of the property he has undertaken to administer. A government, like a trustee, is responsible for the estate. Its business is sound investments, not the encouragement of deserving institutions or the succour of honest, poor men overwhelmed by adversity. Pity and prejudice are equally out of place when ministers, in whom king or people has placed the serious confidence of decision, come to determine the tremendous issues of alliances and wars."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Alexander Hamilton: An Essay on American Union (1906), pp. 333-334
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/F._S._Oliver
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
F. S. Oliver
Frederick Scott Oliver (20 February 1864 – 3 June 1934), was a prominent Scottish political writer and businessman who advocated tariff reform and imperial union for the British Empire. He played an important role in the Round Table movement, collaborated in the downfall of Prime Minister H. H. Asquith's wartime government and its replacement by David Lloyd George in 1916, and pressed for "home rule all round" to resolve the political conflict between Britain and Irish nationalists.
10 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by F. S. Oliver →
Related Quotes
"The spirit of the nation is a great force, but it is one which cannot be always on the alert, and while it sleeps, th…"
"The only two men who really seem to understand that we are at war are Winston and Lloyd George. Both have faults whic…"
"Danger is the inseparable companion of honour. The greatest deeds in history were not done by people who thought of s…"
"If a country will not stand up for its rights it must certainly lose them. The spirit of giving in is the most fatal …"
"[W]e have ever in our minds what our easy-going fellow-countrymen are so apt to forget—that an unceasing and desperat…"
"[T]he Oliver of these pages [i]s essentially an incipient fascist... His ideal clearly is the nation-in-arms, interne…"
"The biography of Hamilton by the late F. S. Oliver and that of Lincoln by Lord Charnwood ought to be known to every e…"
"[T]hat remarkable man, Fred Oliver...was also engaged in writing his study of Sir Robert Walpole (entitled The Endles…"
"The nationalist of the type of Justice Wilson clings steadfastly to the essential principle of home rule for local pu…"
"The more I thought about it, the more obsessed I became with the idea of a swimming journey. I started to dream ever …"