"The important point is, however, that there is more fact and realism in the wildest and most elegant old fictions about disinherited dukes and long–lost daughters than there is in this Eugenist attempt to make the poor all of a piece—a sort of black fungoid growth that is ceaselessly increasing in a chasm. There is a cheap sneer at poor landladies: that they always say they have seen better days. Nine times out of ten they say it because it is true. What can be said of the great mass of Englishmen, by anyone who knows any history, except that they have seen better days? And the landlady’s claim is not snobbish, but rather spirited; it is her testimony to the truth in the old tales of which I spoke: that she ought not to be so poor or so servile in status; that a normal person ought to have more property and more power in the State than that. Such dreams of lost dignity are perhaps the only things that stand between us and the cattle–breeding paradise now promised. Nor are such dreams by any means impotent. I remember Mr. T.P. O’Connor wrote an interesting article about Madame Humbert, in the course of which he said that Irish peasants, and probably most peasants, tended to have a half–fictitious family legend about an estate to which they were entitled. This was written in the time when Irish peasants were landless in their land; and the delusion doubtless seemed all the more entertaining to the landlords who ruled them and the money–lenders who ruled the landlords. But the dream has conquered the realities. The phantom farms have materialised. Merely by tenaciously affirming the kind of pride that comes after a fall, by remembering the old civilisation and refusing the new, by recurring to an old claim that seemed to most Englishmen like the lie of a broken–down lodging–house keeper at Margate—by all this the Irish have got what they want, in solid mud and turf.Read more at location 20407"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Eugenics_and_Other_Evils
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Eugenics and Other Evils
21 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Eugenics and Other Evils →
Related Quotes
"By a quaint paradox, we generally miss the meaning of simple stories because we are not subtle enough to understand t…"
"We can find, for instance, a very good working case in those old puritanical nursery tales about the terrible punishm…"
"Now the trouble of the nineteenth century very largely came from the loss of this; the loss of what we may call the n…"
"The modern sceptic was drugged against all that was natural in the supernatural. And this was why the modern tyrant m…"
"There is one idea of this kind that runs through most popular tales (those, for instance, on which Shakespeare is so …"
"But the modern capitalist did not read fairy–tales, and never looked for the little omens at the turnings of the road…"
"The experiment of Individualism—the keeping of the worker half in and half out of work—was far too ingenious not to c…"
"The time came at last when the rather reckless breeding in the abyss below ceased to be a supply, and began to be som…"
"Thus all the factors—the bodily exhaustion, the harassing fear of hunger, the reckless refuge in sexuality, and the b…"
"'But there was another way. And towards this the employer’s ideas began, first darkly and unconsciously, but now more…"