"If philosophy aims at being a theoretical mode of thought and speech, can it have a rhetorical character and be expressed in rhetorical forms? The answer seems obvious. Theoretical thinking, as a rational process, excludes every rhetorical element because pathetic influences—the influences of feeling—disturb the clarity of rational thought. … To prove means to show something to be something, on the basis of something. To have something through which something is shown and explained definitively is the foundation of our knowledge. Apodictic, demonstrative speech is the kind of speech which establishes the definition of a phenomenon by tracing it back to ultimate principles, or archai. It is clear that the first archai of any proof and hence of knowledge cannot be proved themselves because they cannot be the object of apodictic, demonstrative, logical speech; otherwise they would not be the first assertions. Their nonderivable, primary character is evident from the fact that we neither can speak nor comport ourselves without them, for both speech and human activity simply presuppose them. But if the original assertions are not demonstrable, what is the character of the speech in which we express them? Obviously this type of speech cannot have a rational-theoretical character. ... Basic premises cannot have an apodictic, demonstrative character and structure but are thoroughly indicative. ... Arche … cannot have a rational but only a rhetorical character. Thus the term "rhetoric" assumes a fundamentally new significance; "rhetoric" is not, nor can it be the art, the technique of an exterior persuasion; it is rather the speech which is the basis of the rational thought."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp. 18-19
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ernesto_Grassi
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Ernesto Grassi
Ernesto Grassi (May 2, 1902 – December 22, 1991) was an Italian philosopher.
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Ernesto Grassi →
Related Quotes
"According to the traditional interpretation Plato’s attitude against rhetoric is a rejection of the doxa, or opinion,…"
"In the second part of the Phaedrus Plato attempts to clarify the nature of “true” rhetoric. … it does not arise from …"
"We are forced to distinguish between three kinds of speech: (1) The external, “rhetorical speech,” in the common mean…"
"The general opinion … is that the humanist tradition is primarily of literary and aesthetical significance rather tha…"
"If Descartes’ main aspirations are directed towards a “first truth,” it follows necessarily that the sphere of pure p…"
"The art of eloquence belongs to the realm of probability because it constantly directs its glance at the specific, va…"
"The defects of rationalistic, critical philosophy are much more important than they appear at first sight. By failing…"
"Vico claims that the aim of philosophy is the problem of "finding," and he identifies the theory of "finding" with "t…"
"In Quintilian’s expositions there appears a note of melancholy when he discovers that toward the decline of life, the…"
"The decisive step in Dante's reflections occurs with the assertion that originally, in an unhistorical time before ma…"