"The English Civil War occupies a strange niche in contemporary memory. To all official appearances, no episode of the country’s modern past is so parenthetical. Leaving no reputable trace in common traditions or public institutions, it looks in established retrospect like a blackout in the growth of the collective psyche. Our only republic remains under ban, a historical freak. Rosebery could raise a statue to Cromwell outside Parliament: eighty years later, Benn could not even get him onto a postage stamp, at a time when Rosa Luxemburg adorned ordinary West German mail. Such treatment, it might be argued, is not without all justice. For in a comparative perspective, did not the English Civil War – however traumatic at the time – prove in the end to be the least significant of the political upheavals that accompanied the birth of the leading nation-states of the capitalist world? Set beside the Dutch Revolt, America’s War for Independence, the French Revolution, Italy’s Risorgimento, the unification of Germany, let alone the Meiji Restoration in Japan, the overthrow of the English monarchy seems of a different order: not a modern starting point of institutional development, more an exotic intermission. If this is so, however, there remains a paradox. For what would be the most barren convulsion has produced the most fertile literature. The volume of modern writing on the French Revolution – the only possible rival – is larger than on the English. But intellectually it is thinner."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Civil wars involving the states and peoples of EuropeMilitary history of EnglandPolitics of the United Kingdom17th-century military history
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Perry Anderson, Spectrum: From Right to Left in the World of Ideas (2005), Ch. 12 : Civil War, Global Distemper: Robert Brenner
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/English_Civil_War
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Related Quotes
"Most of the Army preachers believed that the New Model was an army of saints who were possessed by the Holy Spirit an…"
"Both of the colony's principal dissenters- the English Puritans and the Scots-Irish- proudly considered themselves to…"
"In the summer of 1642 the First Civil War between King and Parliament had broken out in England. Initially both sides…"
"Despite these views it is doubtful that the rank and file of the New Model Army were as deeply imbued with religious …"
"William Cavendish, Duke of Newcastle (1592-1676) commanded the Royalists in northern England, and during 1643 made he…"
"When a civil war began in the 1640s between the King's forces and the Parliamentary forces, many English religious di…"
"Prince Rupert was more than an inspiring leader; despite his youth he had wide experience of continental warfare, and…"
"England in August 1642 was in the midst of harvest, the fields covered in shocks of corn or standing golden brown rea…"
"It is fairly easy to conjure up in the imagination a picture of the New Model Army as a Bible-reading, Psalm-singing …"
"You have satisfaction in your conscience that you are in the right; that the king ought not to grant what is required…"