"One can, of course, understand the concern over the extremes of Hindu nationalism given Europe’s own bitter history of Aryanism, although the fact is that much of the impetus fueling the ‘revisionism’ of the Indo-Aryan issue stems from distrust of the motives and agendas underpinning the entire construction and pursuit of the Indo-European homeland quest by Europeans in the 19th and 20th centuries in the first place. Anyone who has at all dabbled with the history of this enterprise, rooted as it is in European racisms, nationalisms and quests for biblical origins, can hardly blame such a priori suspicion in the post-colonial climate of Indian historiography. ‘After all, much of the scholarship on the history of the Indian subcontinent was formulated during the colonial and imperial heyday of the 19th century. We thus have a complex situation where, on the one hand, there are valid and serious grounds for concern over nationalistic appropriation of myths of origin in present day India, and, on the other, equally valid grounds for submitting the entire Indo-European/Indo-Aryan locating enterprise to post-colonial scrutiny."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Historians from the United StatesAcademics from the United KingdomNon-fiction authors from the United KingdomHarvard University staff
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Edwin Bryant
44 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Edwin Bryant →
Related Quotes
"The Indo-Aryan problem is likely to remain unresolved for the foreseeable future, so we might as well attempt to addr…"
"Since there is a tendency to stereotype any local reconsiderations of ancient Indian history whatsoever as nationalis…"
"One must be cautious about contributing to a sort of Indological McCarthyism whereby anyone reconsidering or challeng…"
"Scholars such as Renfrew and Gamkrelidze and Ivanov can radically challenge established Indo-European homeland theori…"
"This all goes to show that ideological analysis, while indispensable in a historiographical study such as this, must …"
"This raises another dimension that the Indigenous Aryan critique forces us to confront: What constitutes authority in…"
"Philology and linguistics can actually offer surprisingly little to compel disenchanted Indian scholars to modify the…"
"It was the testimony of the Bible that originally led scholars to propose the existence of a linguistically unified g…"
"Although in various other academic fields and area studies, such as race science, postcolonial scholarship has comple…"
"In conclusion, any objective and honest attempt at presenting a comprehensive account of the pre-historic period in S…"