""The serious meaning of a concept," writes James, following Peirce, "lies in the concrete difference to some one which its being true will make. Strive to bring all debated conceptions to that "pragmatic" test, and you will escape vain wrangling. … If it can make no practical difference whether a given statement be true or false, then the statement has no real meaning." If the method defined in this passage be accepted, and I can not see how any one can fail to accept it even if one prove unfaithful to it afterwards, then could anything more fully illustrate the meaning of the 'meaningless' than that hypothesis of other minds in which the analogy argument culminates? Whatever may be said for the reasoning, is its conclusion at least right? Alas, I can not know. If right, my experience cannot inform me if wrong, my experience cannot disillusion me. It makes no practical difference to me whether I am right or wrong. Pragmatic conclusion: I cannot have made a meaningful hypothesis."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Philosophers from the United StatesUniversity of Pennsylvania alumniUniversity of Pennsylvania faculty
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p. 5
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Edgar_A._Singer%2C_Jr.
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Edgar A. Singer, Jr.
Edgar Arthur Singer, Jr. (November 13, 1873 – April 4, 1954) was an American philosopher, Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, and proponent of .
13 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Edgar A. Singer, Jr. →
Related Quotes
"Art is (1) a messenger of discontent, yet (2) no teacher of new ideals, but rather (3) an inspiration to each it touc…"
"All the categories of life and mind are to my understanding of them teleological."
"The straightest way to the heart of old matters is an old letter."
""All things excellent are as difficult as they are rare." These words which bring to a close Spinoza's masterpiece Et…"
"I have somewhere found it recorded that as Johann Gottlieb Fichte progressed with his first reading of Kant's "Critiq…"
"Looking back over the years that have lapsed since this was written, I cannot say that James's prophecy as to the fut…"
"I have tried to show pragmatism as a moment in the swing of thought from realism to idealism, and how for it the most…"
"We may not feel as confident as once we did that the way to truth lies all open before us the moment we have brought …"
"It is seldom given to philosophers to enter into one another's enthusiasms, but they are sometimes allowed to share a…"
"Singer's historical study focused on how we know; how we learn facts and laws and the relationship between these. He …"