"Recently, E.O. Wilson's sociobiology has offered the traditionalist view on gender in an argument which applies Darwinian ideas of natural selection to human behavior. Wilson and his followers reason that human behaviors which are "adaptive" for group survival become encoded in the genes, and they include in these behavjors such complex traits as altruism, loyalty, and maternalism. They not only reason that groups practicing a sex-based division of labor in which women function as child-rearers and nurturers have an evolutionary advantage, but they claim such behavior somehow becomes part of our genetic heritage, in that the necessary psychological and physical propensities for such societal arrangements are selectively developed and genetically selected. Mothering is not only a socially assigned role but one fitting women's physical and psychological needs. Here, once again, biological determinism becomes prescriptive, in fact a political defense of the status quo in scientific language. Feminist critics have revealed the circular reasoning, absence of evidence and unscientific assumptions of Wilsonian sociobiology. From the point of view of the nonscientist, the most obvious fallacy of sociobiologists is their ahistoricity in disregarding the fact that modern men and women do not live in a state of nature. The history of civilization describes the process by which humans have distanced themselves from nature by inventing and perfecting culture. Traditionalists ignore technological changes, which have made it possible to bottle-feed infants safely and raise them to adulthood with caretakers other than their own mothers. They ignore the implications of changing life spans and changing life cycles. Until communal hygiene and modern medical knowledge cut infant mortality to a level where parents could reasonably expect each child born to them to live to adulthood, women did indeed have to bear many children in order for a few of them to survive. Similarly, longer life expectancy and lower infant mortality altered the life cycles of both men and women. These developments were connected with industrialization and occurred in Western civilization (for whites) toward the end of the nineteenth century, occurring later for the poor and for minorities due to the uneven distribution of health and social services. Whereas up to 1870 child-rearing and marriage were co-terminus-that is, one or both parents could expect to die before the youngest child reached adulthood-in modern American society husbands and wives can expect to live together for twelve years after their youngest child has reached adulthood, and women can expect to outlive their husbands by seven years." Nevertheless, traditionalists expect women to follow the same roles and occupations that were functional and species-essential in the Neolithic."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Novelists from the United StatesAcademics from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesBiologists from the United StatesZoologists from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Gerda Lerner The Creation of Patriarchy (1986)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/E._O._Wilson
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
E. O. Wilson
Edward Osborne Wilson (10 June 1929 – 26 December 2021) was an American entomologist and biologist known for his work on ecology, evolution, and sociobiology. A two-time winner of the Pulitzer Prize for General Non-Fiction, Wilson is also known for his advocacy for environmentalism, and his secular-humanism ideas pertaining to religious and ethical matters.
88 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by E. O. Wilson →
Related Quotes
"Piaget, who was originally trained as a biologist, views intellectual development as an interaction of an inherited g…"
"The rules followed are tight enough to produce a broad overlap in the decisions taken by all individuals and hence a …"
"The race to make discoveries of the greatest generality, to solve the major problems in the 'mainstream of biology,' …"
"[Biology has] become the paramount science, exceeding other disciplines, including physics and chemistry at least, in…"
"This planet can be a paradise in the 22nd century."
"My definition of a scientist is that you can complete the following sentence: ‘he or she has shown that…’,”"
"Wonderful theory, wrong species. (On Marxism, which he considered more suited to ants than to humans.)"
"The toxic mix of religion and tribalism has become so dangerous as to justify taking seriously the alternative view, …"
"Will we solve the crises of next hundred years? asked Krulwich. “Yes, if we are honest and smart,” said Wilson. “The …"
"The ideal scientist thinks like a poet and only later works like a bookkeeper."