"Historiography today is not in that state of fermentation to be found in fields such as literary criticism and Continental philosophy. Historians tend to pride themselves on their immunity to the wormlike doubt and self-reflective scrutiny that have appeared in other areas of inquiry, notably those infiltrated by recent French thought. Far from seeing recent critical initiatives as holding forth the angelic promise of a reformation or even a renaissance in historical studies, many historians have been seized with what might almost be called a counter-reformational zeal in reasserting orthodox procedures. But the contemporary historical profession is not a solid block, and even the most traditional scholars show an openness to at least a few newer movements. If one were to generalize somewhat rashly about prominent trends in the profession, one might list the following: an inclination to rely on a social definition of context as an explanatory matrix; a shift toward an interest in popular culture; a reconceptualization of culture in terms of collective discourses, mentalities, world views, and even “languages”; a redefinition of intellectual history as the study of social meaning as historically constituted; and an archivally based documentary realism that treats artifacts as quarries for facts in the reconstitution of societies and cultures of the past."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesNon-fiction authors from the United StatesHistorians from the United StatesHarvard University alumni
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chap. 2 : The Cheese and the Worms: The Cosmos of a Twentieth-Century Historian
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Dominick_LaCapra
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Dominick LaCapra
18 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Dominick LaCapra →
Related Quotes
"Rhetoric involves a dialogical understanding of discourse and of “truth” itself in contrast to a monological idea of …"
"Rhetoric includes “performative” uses of language that make a difference in one’s relation to the object of study. Th…"
"Rhetoric highlights the problem of how one reads texts. It even raises the question of whether historians are trained…"
"Rhetoric exceeds not only documentary or referential but all utilitarian, workaday, and instrumental functions of lan…"
"Rhetoric engages the dialectic of recognition among speakers, of which certain forms of persuasion are only the monol…"
"Rhetoric raises the issues of ambivalence and role tension in language use and their relation to the interaction of d…"
"The lack of attention to the problem of rhetoric, or the simple dichotomy between science and rhetoric, induces a ten…"
"At present, historians are quite willing to listen to neighbors in the social sciences, but the less manageable contr…"
"Contemporary sociocultural history was in part motivated by a justifiable revolt against an abstracted history of ide…"
"I have no synoptic formula for resolving the various problems I have tried to raise. I would simply end by saying tha…"