"The last of Smith’s regrettable failures is one for which he is overwhelmingly famous – the Division of labor. How can it be that the famous opening chapters of his book, and the pin factory he gave immortality, can be considered a failure? Are they not cited as often as any passages in all economics? Indeed, over the generations they are. The failure is different: almost no one used or now uses theory of Division of labor, for the excellent reason that there is scarcely such a theory. … there is no standard, operable theory to describe what Smith argued to be the mainspring of economic progress. Smith gave the Division of labor an immensely convincing presentation – it seems to me as persuasive a case for the power of specialization today as it appeared to Smith. Yet there is no evidence, so far as I know, of any serious advance in theory of the subject since his time, and specialization is not an integral part of the modern theory of production, which may well be an explanation for the fact that the modern theory of economies of scale is little more than a set of alternative possibilities."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
George Stigler (1976). “The Successes and Failures of Professor Smith”. Journal of Political Economy, 84, 1199-1213
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Division_of_labor
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Division of labor
101 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Division of labor →
Related Quotes
"Early British economists held that the application of the principle of Division of labor was the basis of manufacture…"
"The first application of this principle must have been made in a very early stage of society; for it must soon have b…"
"Thus we are brought to the third circle of this hell, which, perhaps, will some day find its Dante. In this third soc…"
"Everyone who achieves strives for totality, and the value of his achievement lies in that totality—that is, in the fa…"
"You can’t treat values like workers, hiring and firing them at will and assigning each a place in an imposed division…"
"The unremitting division of labour resulted in admirable levels of productivity. The company’s success appeared to be…"
"As yet no aesthetic standards have been introduced. Complexity is not an aesthetic criterion. It is a quality associa…"
"In Amazon societies... no division of labor based on sex seems to have existed... Although Amazon leaders existed and…"
"Solis etenim in uno convenientibus actu eadem loquela remansit: puta cunctis architectoribus una, cunctis saxa volven…"
"The error in positivism is that it takes as its standard of truth the contingently given division of labor, that betw…"