"The academic scope of the present volume may be clearly stated at the outset, It begins by arguing that one of the underlying assump- tions of Western Indology is a feeling of superiority in relation to India, especially modern India and Indians. This feeling of superi- ority is expressed in various ways. On one level, there are recurrent attempts to link all fundamental changes in Indian society and history to Western intervention in some form. The image of ancient India which was foisted on Indians through hegemonic texts emanating from Western schools of Indology had in mind an India that was steeped in philosophical, religious and literary lores and unable to change herself without external influence, be it in the form of Alexander the Great, Roman ships carrying gold or the Governor-Generals of the British East India Company. On a different level, expressions of Western superiority can be more direct and encompass a wide range of forms: patronizing and/ or contemptuous reviews of Indian publications, allusions to per- sonal hardships while working in India, refusal to acknowledge Indians as âagents of knowledgeâ, or even blatant arrogance which makes one wonder if the civilized values of Western academia have not left its Indology mostly untouched."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p. 1
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Dilip_Kumar_Chakrabarti
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Dilip Kumar Chakrabarti
27 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Dilip Kumar Chakrabarti â
Related Quotes
"âIn several Indian universities that I can think of â Delhi University, for instance -- students were positively discâŚ"
"The communists had a free run so far, their opponents being no match in the psychological warfare launched by the comâŚ"
"Dilip Chakrabarti's comments (1986) are of relevance here: "Archaeology must take the entire basic framework of the AâŚ"
"After Independence . . . [Indians]âespecially those from the ââestablishedââ familiesâwere no longer apprehensive of âŚ"
"If one goes through the archeological literature on Egypt and Mesopotamia, [especially] the areas where Western scholâŚ"
"Chakrabarti (1997) has nothing but scorn for the Indian intellectual elites who "fail to see the need of going beyondâŚ"
"Thus, anti-Aryan invasionist scholarship, in its turn, is stereotyped as being subser- vient to secular, Marxist ideoâŚ"
"Chakrabarti (1997) is not at all reticent in stating: It is the interplay of race, language and culture which has proâŚ"
"Chakrabarti (1997) is forcefully pronouncing in print what many Indian intellectuals will reveal in private conversatâŚ"
"First, this hypothesis of a population movement from Iran and elsewhere to Peninsular India does not conform to the gâŚ"