"At one point I thought of directing your attention to the medico-legal relations of Insanity, with a special reference to the oproprium which has so often been thrown upon medical witnesses for the unseemly differences and contradictions displayed by them in our courts of law in questions as to the existence of Imbecility and Insanity. I have strong conviction that these differences and contradictions are entirely due to the “lawers”, and the very imperfect and erroneous legal defintions of Idiocy and Insanity, and nor to the “Doctors”. And I think we ought, both as individuals and as an Association, to use all our energies and influence to bring about a revision of the legal distinctions regarding Insanity, so as to get their distinctions and definitions in conformity with ours, or, more correctly speaking, in conformity with nature and facts;-with those descriptions and distinctions which we have derived from the careful study of mental disease. Let the legal responsibility, or legal capacities of each class so recognized, be at the same time fixed and determined by law, and then-and then only-will the greater part of the difficulties and discrepancies of medical testimony entirely disappear."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp.3-4
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/David_Skae
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
David Skae
David Skae MD, FRCSEd (5 July 1814 – 18 April 1873) was a Scottish physician specialising in psychological medicine.
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by David Skae →
Related Quotes
"From my own personal experience, then, and from what I have observed in the practical experience of others-of the man…"
"The next point which has struck me in my experience, both in respect to others and myself, whether as regards cases p…"
"My proposition, then, is this-that we ought to classify all the varieties of Insanity to use a botanical term, in the…"
"The first natural group is obviously “Idiocy”, including Imbecility under all its various forms and degrees, until we…"
"The second natural group appears to me to be the Epileptics. Epilepsy is emphatically a disease of childhood, and whe…"
"The third natural family I would assign to the Masturbators. Although I designate this family by the cause only which…"
"Next comes a well-known group, but with protean lineaments, yet familiar to all of us, cases of Hysterical Mania. I n…"
"The Insanity of the critical period of life is a form very familiar to us ; and I have no doubt you have recognised a…"
"The next natural order is doubtless Senile Insanity, occasionally commencing in the form of Mania, more frequently in…"
"I would strongly press upon you this view of the subject, — one to which I have already referred, that this is, in fa…"